Abigail Irsay, 30, was fined more than £240 and given six penalty points at Llanelli Magistrates' Court after pleading guilty to careless driving when she overtook a cyclist on a country road in Pembrokeshire. The decision has sparked a debate among Wales Online readers about the safety and legality of overtaking cyclists.
Details of the incident
On April 5 this year, Irsay was driving her Vauxhall Corsa on the A4075 Carew Lane, north of the A477, in Pembrokeshire. She overtook a cyclist on the road, and footage of the manoeuvre was uploaded by the cyclist to GoSafe as part of its Operation Snap system.
Irsay was charged with driving a mechanically propelled vehicle on a road or in a public place without due care and attention. She pleaded guilty and was sentenced at Llanelli Magistrates' Court last month.
The court heard: "The defendant conducted the overtake with the majority of their vehicle within the same lane of travel as the cyclist and while other vehicles were travelling towards the defendant in the opposite lane. The standard of driving of the defendant fell below that of a reasonable and competent driver."
Footage of the overtaking manoeuvre shows the cyclist first being passed by a truck towing a small caravan, which moves predominantly into the opposing lane of traffic as it goes by the cyclist.
Readers' views
One reader, David F, made this observation: "Imagine the cyclist is the size of a car so you have to go fully into the other lane to pass. If you can't do that, then wait. Don't squeeze through in the same lane or you will get done."
Christina D said: "I passed a group of cyclists going uphill recently. They were spread out over about 100 metres between the first and last rider and while I took every precaution and passed them safely I encountered temporary traffic lights about half a mile on and while I was waiting at the red light the bikes caught up, mounted the pavement and then proceeded past the lights without stopping. When my light turned green, I had to pass them all again! Are cyclists exempt from stopping at traffic lights?"
Dave G added: "When stuck behind a posse of cyclists labouring up a hill on a country lane, spare a thought for how much more unpleasant your drive would be if those cyclists each chose to drive their car that day instead of their bike! If you met them coming the other way, you'd be manoeuvring and swearing for ages!"
Stuart D said: "It was a bit of a stupid overtake with cars coming at her, she literally had to wait 10 seconds to have a clear road to overtake."
Mark A said: "The problem is you cannot tell exactly how far from the cyclist she was on this video or if the cyclist moved out a little."
Anthony B suggested: "Ignore the cyclist angle - look at the oncoming car! They were nearly in the ditch trying to avoid her. THAT's why she got done!"
Tommy Finn agreed: "To be fair, she got six points for nearly wiping the driver out coming the other way."
Leanne B said: "Go past as if you are overtaking a car. Same space. Fully on the other side preferably. There is no room for error and the cyclist could die. It’s not rocket science."
Carl F said: "When I see a cyclist, I imagine it being the most important person in my life and thus I want to ensure their safety. Because for someone else - that cyclist means the world to them and there is no need to endanger a cyclist or pedestrian to save a second or two that you spend minutes waiting at the next stoplight or roundabout anyway."
Simon W wrote: "She was nowhere near far enough away. People need to realise driving a car is a privilege. Everyone deserves to get home safely after their journey."
Suzanne E said: "When cycling on the road, I am just generally scared of impatient and inconsiderate drivers, so I try not to do it anymore."
Steve P said: "There are three aggravating factors with this overtake. Yes, the overtake was a little close, but in my experience, this would warrant a warning letter for most offenders. The key here is speed and the oncoming drivers. Those three elements are all part of Operation Snap's mindset."
Alan G said: "Without even watching the film, you can see that she has cut in too close from the picture. She's already moving in. Think of it this way - if that was a car, not a bike, and you were driving it, all drivers would be saying she cut up and endangered the vehicle she overtook. She should have left about 6 feet - She didn't."
Stewart A added: "So I'm driving a 44-ton articulated vehicle, acceleration non-existent, and come across two cyclists doubled up doing 10mph. Two miles later I've 16 motors queued up behind me because I can't 'safely overtake', guess who gets the blame for holding everybody up?"
Readers were invited to comment below to have their say on whether they agree with the fine and points.