Thomas Markle Sr, the Duchess of Sussex's father, has been ruled competent to stand trial in the US on a charge of possessing child pornography, following a psychiatric assessment that concluded he was exaggerating his lack of recall to avoid prosecution.
The 82-year-old was arrested earlier this month after FBI agents seized material from two Los Angeles storage units he had rented for nearly two decades, including slides, film negatives and books that contained suspected child sex abuse material.
Psychiatric Evaluation Findings
Dr Amie Gerodimos, an assistant professor at the Department of Psychiatry and Behavioural Neurosciences at the University of South Florida, conducted a forensic psychiatric interview with Markle Sr in the medical unit at Pinellas County Jail on November 12. Her 16-page report was submitted to the judge.
In her report, Dr Gerodimos stated: "It is my opinion, with reasonable medical certainty, that Mr Markle is competent to stand trial." She added: "It is my opinion, with reasonable medical certainty, that Mr Markle does have sufficient present ability to understand the nature and consequences of the proceedings against him and to assist properly in his defence."
The doctor said that, in her opinion, Markle Sr was "malingering because he is exaggerating a lack of recall or understanding of the charges in order to avoid criminal prosecution".
Details of the Case
Markle Sr was detained by FBI agents on November 6. He was initially released on conditional bail but was taken back into custody days later after removing his electronic monitoring tag.
He is charged with one count of possession of child pornography and, if convicted, would face at least 20 years in federal prison. The investigation began after he was reported to police in the Philippines and the FBI last month by his son, Thomas Markle Jr, who allegedly found illegal images in his father's belongings in Cebu City. Markle Jr told The Sun newspaper he had tipped off authorities about the LA storage facilities.
Markle Sr's Responses During Interview
During the interview, Dr Gerodimos noted that Markle Sr's behaviour "was calm and co-operative" and he "made good eye contact". She reported that he repeatedly said "You'll have to forgive me, my memory is gone" and pointed to his age.
When discussing the allegation, Markle Sr said: "I don't understand about the case at all. I have no idea. I don't know about the charge. I don't know, I don't know, I don't know. Why am I here? What have I done?" He added: "I don't have any child porn. I have no pictures of naked kids."
He acknowledged the allegation was "very serious" and said: "I am sure it's a felony. I am sure it's prison time." Dr Gerodimos noted that his face flushed when the allegation was discussed.
Markle Sr told the doctor that he had a son named Thomas Junior and a daughter named Meghan Markle, pointing out that she "might have heard of Meghan". He also said: "I think my son is crucifying me at this moment" and spoke about mocking his son for not having gone past the eighth grade in school.
Dr Gerodimos wrote in her report: "The essential feature of malingering is the production of false or grossly exaggerated physical or psychological problems, motivated by external incentives. He stated excessively, 'I don't know', diverting attention to his age and neurocognitive disorder, before providing additional information. He understood the seriousness of the nature of the charges."
Following the assessment, the court found "the defendant is competent". Meghan, who moved back to the UK with the Duke of Sussex in August, said she was "deeply distressed" at the accusations against her father, from whom she has been estranged since before her 2018 wedding. A future court date in California has not yet been set.