High Court rules predatory doctor should be struck off
High Court: predatory doctor should be struck off

A High Court judge has ruled that a doctor who carried out 'sexually motivated examinations' on two junior colleagues should have been erased from the medical register, overturning an earlier decision to suspend him.

Dr Khush Bakhat Muhammad Zeeshan was initially handed a 12-month suspension in March after a tribunal found he had conducted the examinations. The incidents took place at the A&E department of the Royal Albert Edward Infirmary in Wigan, after the women spoke of their health concerns in front of him.

Appeal overturns suspension

The Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service had described Zeeshan's conduct as 'predatory' and 'opportunistic'. The panel ruled that he had 'exploited the health concerns of two female junior colleagues', judging this to be 'serious misconduct'. However, it decided on a suspension rather than erasure, citing testimonials from colleagues, actions taken by Zeeshan around consent, and a lack of further incidents in the five years since his actions were reported.

Following an appeal from the General Medical Council (GMC), High Court judge Mr Justice Squires ruled that the tribunal's decision was 'wrong'. The court report states that the tribunal's decision 'departed' from guidance around sexual misconduct, which advises that any sanction short of erasure will 'generally be inappropriate' when sexual misconduct is found to be sexually motivated.

Public confidence undermined

Mr Justice Squires said it was 'very difficult to see anything in the surrounding context that would mitigate it or render it less serious than it at first appears'. He ruled that the incidents 'have the capacity to significantly undermine public confidence in the medical profession'.

He added: "Patients will often see doctors in situations of acute vulnerability, and they need to be able to trust implicitly that if a doctor asks them to remove clothing or touches them intimately, that is being done solely because it is clinically necessary, and not in any way for the doctor's personal sexual gratification."

The judge also dismissed the tribunal's acceptance of a lack of subsequent incidents as a justifiable reason to depart from the guidance, noting that the second incident occurred less than a month after the first and that Zeeshan had been under investigation since then.

Details of the incidents

Zeeshan had denied the allegations, but the original tribunal found the accounts presented by the two women to be more believable. The first woman, named as Ms B in the report, had complained of back pain, with Zeeshan offering to 'manipulate' her back. The tribunal found, 'on the balance of probabilities', he went on to straddle her and touch her on the bottom and under her clothes. A medical expert told the panel there was no reason for Zeeshan to do these things as part of 'any standard musculoskeletal spinal manipulation technique'.

The second woman, Ms A, was speaking to colleagues about a swollen lymph node in her groin. Zeeshan offered to check her armpits for lumps, telling her she had a 'higher risk of breast cancer' as a woman. The panel found, 'on the balance of probabilities', Zeeshan went on to examine her breasts, which Ms A said she had not expected or consented to. While a medical expert said the breast exam was part of a 'competent' procedure of this type, he added it was not 'reasonable' to do this without 'explicit consent'.

A GMC spokesperson said: "We welcome the High Court's decision. There is no place for any form of sexual assault, harassment or misconduct in the medical profession." The GMC website now shows that Zeeshan has been erased from the medical practitioner register, legally barring him from practicing in the UK.