Two female prison officers who had secret relationships with drug-dealing inmate brothers have lost their Court of Appeal bid to reduce their sentences. Jai Gascoyne, 25, and Elle Walton, 27, were jailed after their inappropriate relationships with convicts Dil Nawaz, 30, and Haq Nawaz, 32, were uncovered.
The women were employed at HMP Buckley Hall when their illicit ties came to light in August 2024 following a tip-off to an anti-corruption unit. An investigation revealed the staff had exchanged Valentine's Day cards, gifts, cash from the brothers' associates, and a flurry of phone calls and social media messages with the prisoners.
Details of the relationships
In August this year, Manchester Crown Court was told how Gascoyne bought matching Amazon necklaces and bracelets engraved with their initials for herself and Dil Nawaz. Messages uncovered during the probe also showed Gascoyne and Walton calling each other "Mrs N".
The court heard that Gascoyne also had inappropriate contact with two other inmates – including messaging prisoner Michael Haigh on Instagram shortly before leaving her role to arrange a cell visit for a "goodbye cuddle". Despite the exchanges of gifts and money, the court heard the relationships never turned sexual and neither woman smuggled contraband into the jail.
Sentences and appeal
Walton, from Bacup, Lancashire, admitted misconduct in a public office over her relationship with Haq Nawaz. Both women pleaded guilty to misconduct and were jailed – with Gascoyne handed 16 months and Walton given 13 months.
The pair took their case to the Court of Appeal, claiming their jail terms were "manifestly excessive" and should have been suspended. Gascoyne's barrister, Nick Cockrell, argued the sentencing judge set the starting point too high at 26 months rather than 20, and failed to properly consider her youth, remorse, personal mitigation and previous good character. Walton's barrister, Michael O'Brien, contended her actions were at the lower end of severity because there was no sexual contact and no contraband was brought into the facility.
Appeal dismissed
Lord Justice Holgate, Mr Justice Griffiths, and Judge Kearl rejected the appeals, finding that both officers acted with their "eyes open" despite having undergone specific anti-corruption training.