A paedophile shook his head as he finally faced justice some 40 years after committing an appalling campaign of sexual abuse. John Hartley's "systematic abuse" still leaves one of his victims unable to look at a jar of the namesake Hartley's jam in the supermarket even decades later. One three-word phrase which he would often repeat in the aftermath of his assaults also leaves her "immediately hearing the words in his voice".
The twice-convicted sex offender also subjected a young boy to a harrowing attack which "ruined his life". Liverpool Crown Court heard Hartley "systematically abused" the girl, who was aged as young as four, "on an almost weekly basis", in the St Helens area during the 1980s. This saw the now 57-year-old, of Stanley Road in Bootle, perform sex acts on his victim before "asking her if she enjoyed it".
Victim's statement read to court
In a statement read to the court on her behalf by prosecution counsel Peter Wilson, she said: "Throughout my life, I have tried to remain positive and be the best person and mother I can be. I have always loved and cared for my children. Despite this, I have often felt like I've been fighting a losing battle inside."
"What happened to me affected every part of my life. I think about this every single day. I find it difficult to sleep, because my mind constantly goes back to what happened. Memories replay over and over again. I've often feared people wouldn't believe me, which has made it very difficult to trust others. I don't believe I'll ever truly trust a man."
"My children have never slept away from home. I've always felt the need to protect them from harm. I constantly worry about my daughter's safety. My children are my whole world, but my fear and anxiety have affected the way I've parented."
"I've gone to great lengths to teach them about safety, because I never wanted them to experience harm. I never let them walk to school or attend sleepovers. Sadly, some of my anxiety has been passed onto them. This causes me a great deal of sadness and guilt."
"Reminders can appear without warning and immediately take me back. Seeing a jar of Hartley's jam while shopping can trigger anxiety and panic. Hearing the words 'is that nice?' is another trigger to me. I immediately hear them in his voice."
"No child should ever have to go through what I experienced. My children have been my reason for continuing. If it weren't for them, I honestly don't believe I would be here today."
"I can't help but wonder what might have been if these events had never happened. What the defendant did has impacted every part of my life. The effects have followed me from childhood into adulthood and continue to affect me every day."
Second victim's account
Hartley also sexually assaulted a boy, then estimated to have been aged between three and seven, on another occasion, with the degrading details of the offence being too graphic for the ECHO to publish. He added in his own statement: "I've been unstable all my life due to what happened to me and I've not coped very well, which has ended up with me getting in trouble with the police, relationships breaking down, not being able to hold down a job and not having friends."
"I often isolate myself away from the world so I don't have to talk to people. John Hartley has ruined my life. I want him to face up to what he's done to me and for ruining my life."
Hartley's 13 previous convictions for 24 offences include two counts of indecent assault in 2006, relating to sexual acts against a teenage girl. He was also handed a further five months later the same year for battery against his elderly mother, who he was a carer for.
Defence and sentencing
Lloyd Morgan, defending, told the court today, Monday: "One of the factors I pray in aid is the difficult start he had to life, with many years spent in care or a children's home. I do bear in mind the contents of the pre-sentence report and the lack of understanding, for want of a better phrase."
"It is now 26 years since the most recent set of offending. In my submission, that is a very powerful factor for the court to consider when looking at the high test of finding him dangerous. Should the court disagree and find him dangerous, given the sort of sentence that he is about to receive, it is unnecessary to pass an extended sentence. The public will be protected by the length of sentence."
"He did have a long history of employment until he had a stroke in 2011. He is continuing to take medication to help him with the ongoing effects of that stroke. Your honour will have seen in the report that the effects include fatigue, it is affecting his memory and his reading and writing."
"He has undergone a high level of difficulties as a result of that condition. He has family support, and there has never been, as far as those people are concerned, any concern regarding his involvement with their children."
Judge's ruling
Hartley was found guilty of seven counts of indecent assault by a jury following a six-day trial earlier this year. Appearing via video link to HMP Liverpool wearing a grey prison issue jumper and glasses, he was seen shaking his head as the judge addressed him this afternoon before being jailed for 12 years.
Sentencing, Judge Neil Flewitt KC said of the first victim: "She describes the fear, anxiety and depression which have plagued her for most of her life. What you did to her has had an impact on her physical and mental health and affected her ability to form healthy relationships."
"She found the trial particularly difficult, suffering panic attacks and being overwhelmed by the process. You could have spared her that anguish if you could have found the courage to acknowledge these offences."
Turning to the second complainant, Judge Flewitt added: "He attributes the instability in his life to what you did to him all those years ago. While I accept there may have been other factors affecting his situation, I have no doubt that your actions contributed to those issues."
"You have several previous convictions, most of which are old and of an entirely different nature. However, one of your previous convictions is remarkably similar. Although people speak highly of you, I am afraid their views carry little weight when set against the seriousness of your offending."
"I take account of your employment history until you suffered a stroke and the impact of your stroke generally. In reality, apart from your age and immaturity at the time of the earlier offences, there is little mitigation of any real value in this case."
"I appreciate that the passage of time has the potential to aggravate or mitigate the seriousness of these offences. This is not a case where there was isolated offending when you were young. Your offending was persistent and continued into adulthood. Far from providing you with mitigation, the passage of time has shown that you have an abiding and unhealthy sexual interest in young children."
"I have no hesitation in concluding that you are a dangerous offender, in that there is a significant risk you will cause serious harm by the commission of further specified offences. You went on, almost 20 years later, to commit similar offences."
"However, given the passage of time since the commission of the most recent sexual offences and the protection to the public that will be provided by a sentence for an offender of particular concern, by a sexual harm prevention order and the provisions of the notification requirement, I do not consider that it is necessary to impose a sentence of life imprisonment or an extended sentence."
With one of his victims seen wiping tears with a tissue in the public gallery, Hartley was also handed an extended licence period of two years. He will be subject to a sexual harm prevention order for 10 years and will be required to sign the sex offenders' register for life.