A holidaymaker died after industrial ducting crashed down inside the Fun Factory entertainment hall at Pontins Brean Sands in Somerset, leading to a £1 million fine for the park's parent company and a suspended prison sentence for a contractor.
Wendy Jones, 68, from Hereford, sustained catastrophic injuries when the ducting plummeted during a packed bingo session on February 20, 2019. She initially survived but remained hospitalised for nearly six months before dying on August 4, 2019. A post-mortem examination established a direct connection between her death and the injuries sustained in the collapse.
Court hears of overloading
On Friday, November 20, Bristol Crown Court was told how over four tonnes of excess soundproofing materials had been positioned atop the ducting during renovation work undertaken several years prior. Britannia Jinky Jersey (BJJ), Pontins' parent company, was fined £1 million after acknowledging a health and safety breach. Contractor Stephen Bennison, 60, from Farington, Lancashire, was given a 10-month prison sentence suspended for 18 months.
Mrs Jones, who was present with her daughter and grandson, suffered a fractured femur, fractured shoulder, broken ribs and a punctured lung. She required assistance leaving the venue in her mobility scooter. Multiple holidaymakers sustained injuries, prompting emergency services to race to the location.
Investigation traces cause
Investigators traced the catastrophe to soundproofing works undertaken in 2015 and 2016. Contractor Bennison had been brought in to cut noise levels at the entertainment venue. Throughout the job, soundproofing slabs were fitted within the ceiling grid, but over four tonnes of surplus slabs and plasterboard fascias were also dumped on top of the industrial ducting.
When worries were flagged at the time, Bennison is said to have reassured management the setup was secure. A survey completed in 2016 nonetheless flagged concerns about overloading within the structure. While some remedial work was done on the ceiling grid, the overloaded ducting stayed put. The investigation revealed warning signs had emerged shortly before the collapse, with guests voicing concerns about visibly bowing ducting to Pontins staff, and some even shifting seats fearing it might come down.
Guilty pleas and impact
In police interviews, Bennison confessed to dumping spare soundproofing slabs atop the ducting to get rid of leftover materials. He also conceded he had never tackled soundproofing work on this magnitude before and possessed no structural qualifications.
In a victim impact statement, Mrs Jones's son James Havard-Jones said: "My Mum's life was cut short because of the incompetence and negligence of others. There is a temptation to describe what happened as an accident. I cannot do that. An accident is something unforeseeable. This was not unforeseeable. This was preventable." He added: "For six months, we watched her move between hospital beds, becoming a shadow of the woman she once was."
The court was told Wendy had been a well-known charity worker, community leader and devoted grandmother. Her daughter Hayley remarked: "People never think that they will go on holiday and then come back without their loved ones and it is not right that this happened to us."
Detective Superintendent Roger Doxsey characterised the collapse as "entirely preventable", stating: "It is a minor miracle, given the weight of the ducting, the nature of its collapse, and the volume of other people present in the Fun Factory at the time of the incident, that more people were not seriously injured and killed."
The proceedings conclude a protracted seven-year inquiry into one of the gravest safety failures ever associated with a UK holiday park.