Florida double murderer executed after final meal and last words
Florida double murderer executed after final meal

Thomas Mitchell Overton, a 71-year-old convicted double murderer, was executed by lethal injection at Florida State Prison in Raiford at 6.19pm on Thursday, November 19, prison officials confirmed. In his final statement, Overton denied the crimes, saying: "I never killed anyone."

Overton was sentenced to death for the murders of 29-year-old Susan "Missy" MacIvor and her 30-year-old husband, Michael, at their Florida Keys home on August 22, 1991. Missy was pregnant with the couple's first child, a baby boy they had named Kyle Patrick.

Final hours and last meal

Hours before the execution, Overton woke at 5am and ate a final meal of fried chicken, white bread, popcorn and milk. According to Department of Corrections officials, he spent his last hours alone, receiving no visitors and declining a meeting with a spiritual advisor.

The execution was the 20th carried out in Florida in 2026, surpassing the previous annual record of 19 set the year before. Governor Ron DeSantis signed Overton's death warrant on October 21.

Crime and investigation

The crime was discovered when Missy failed to arrive for her job as a third-grade teacher at Key Largo Elementary School. Worried colleagues alerted neighbours, who entered the couple's two-storey house near TavernAero Airport and found the victims.

Police found the home's phone lines had been cut with wire clippers. Both victims had their eyes and mouths covered before being strangled with neckties. Michael had also been bludgeoned over the head, while Missy was tied up with belts from a dresser and sexually assaulted before being killed.

Detectives spent five years investigating before a breakthrough in 1996. Overton, a career burglar living in nearby Tavernier, attempted suicide with a razor blade while held on an unrelated burglary charge. Police matched his DNA to semen found on the MacIvors' bedsheets.

Conviction and reaction

Further investigation revealed Missy had encountered Overton three weeks before the murders. She had told her sister that a worker at a local Amoco petrol station "gave her the creeps", and records showed she had paid $7.35 for fuel with a personal cheque bearing her home address while Overton was on shift.

A jury found Overton guilty of the double murder in 1999 and recommended the death penalty by votes of 9-3 for Missy's murder and 8-4 for Michael's. In 2001, he received a life sentence for the 1996 burglary.

After the execution, Monroe County Sheriff Rick Ramsay, one of the first patrol officers at the scene in 1991, called the killings one of the "most heinous" cases of his 40-year career. "I will never forget and am thankful for a final end to this 35-year case," Ramsay said. "Final closure for the family, friends and citizens is long overdue."

Monroe State Attorney Dennis Ward described Overton as a "cold-blooded killer", adding: "Justice has been served, but no execution can undo the suffering he caused or return three innocent lives. Michael, Missy, and Kyle Patrick MacIvor will never be forgotten."

Campaigners against capital punishment, including Floridians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty, acknowledged the brutality of the killings but pointed out that Overton was a military veteran who had suffered abuse at the now-closed Dozier School for Boys, claiming the execution "set a grim record" under DeSantis' leadership.