A coroner has ruled that British army soldiers “lost control” and used unreasonable force in the killing of five civilians in Belfast in 1972. The inquest judge, Mr Justice Scoffield, found that none of the deceased should have been shot under the circumstances.
The killings occurred on 9 July 1972 in the Springhill and Westrock areas of west Belfast. Among the victims were two teenagers, a father of six, and a Catholic priest. The judge stated that four of the dead were unarmed, and it was unclear whether the fifth carried a weapon. Soldiers A and E were found to have overreacted to perceived threats, fired prematurely, and breached the 'yellow card' rules governing lethal force.
Father Noel Fitzpatrick, 42, and Patrick Butler, 37, were killed by the same bullet while crossing a road. Margaret Gargan, 13, was shot in the head while talking to friends. David McCafferty, 15, was shot in the back while attempting to retrieve the priest's body. The court heard McCafferty was a member of the IRA youth wing but was unarmed and considered an innocent victim. John Dougal, 16, was probably fleeing for cover when shot.
The coroner rejected claims that soldiers were reacting to a mass coordinated attack, citing brigade radio logs that undermined that narrative. He noted the soldiers' youth and inexperience, and their ignorance of the political context during the bloodiest year of the Troubles, six months after Bloody Sunday.
Families welcomed the verdict. Betty Kennedy, McCafferty's sister, said it brought “long-awaited clarity and justice.” Natasha Butler said inquests can deliver truth even after 54 years. Sinn Féin MP Paul Maskey said the verdict confirmed the victims posed no threat and highlighted the army's impunity.