The Prevent anti-terrorism scheme missed opportunities to protect the public from the killer of MP Sir David Amess and the Southport dance class murderer, an official report has found. The review, by David Anderson, the interim independent reviewer of Prevent, identified a 'long string of failings' in both cases.
In the Amess case, the attacker Ali Harbi Ali was referred to Prevent in 2014 but his case was closed after just one mentoring session, instead of the planned seven. Anderson noted that the mentoring programme 'was allowed to peter out when it had hardly begun.' Ali later stabbed Sir David to death in October 2021.
The report also examined the case of Axel Rudakubana, who murdered three young girls at a Southport dance class. Prevent declined to take on his case three times after teachers raised concerns from 2019 to 2021, including that he had brought a knife to school and expressed interest in mass violence. Anderson concluded that had his case been examined by the Channel programme, 'he might have been offered a mentor who could have made a difference.'
Anderson recommends a potential expansion of Prevent to include individuals with 'no fixed ideology but a fascination with extreme violence or mass casualty attacks.' He also suggests formally connecting Prevent to a broader safeguarding system. The Amess family has called for a full public inquiry, which the government has so far refused.