Two Gwent Police officers have been dismissed without notice after a misconduct hearing found they lied about carrying out home searches during a missing persons investigation. PC Richard Hardwick, 32, and PC Lauren Livingstone, 27, failed in their duty to search for two missing young women and then falsely claimed they had done so.
The officers were involved in the search for Eve Smith, 21, and Sophie Russon, 20, who were among five passengers found in a crashed car in the St Mellons area of Cardiff on March 6, 2023. The vehicle took 46 hours to be discovered, by which time Eve, Darcy Ross, 21, and Rafel Jeanne, 24, had died. Sophie Russon and Shane Loughlin, 32, survived the crash.
Misconduct Panel Findings
The panel heard that the officers' "dishonest" use of official logs undermined the missing persons investigation. Their actions were described as "deliberate and misleading", and the panel remarked that their conduct may have compromised the investigation. Both were dismissed without notice.
The panel said their actions caused a serious level of harm, and although they were junior officers, both had experience in missing persons investigations and knew searches should have been carried out. They then deliberately misled others, including on the investigation log, in conversations with their supervisor and the police watchdog. This amounted to "operational dishonesty".
Background to the Case
The hearing was told that officers had viewed Snapchat videos from the Friday night showing the women in high spirits at a party, and assumed they had simply chosen to stay out longer without telling their parents, even though they had been uncontactable for 24 hours. Stephen Morley, barrister for Gwent Police professional standards, called for the two officers to be dismissed and said their behaviour involved the "fabrication of evidence in an ongoing missing persons inquiry".
Sophie's father Nathan Russon, Eve's mother Emma Borg, and Eve's brother Zaine Smith all told the panel that the two officers visited their addresses on the night of March 4, 2023, but did not search them. Hardwick led the search at Sophie's address, while Livingstone took the lead at Eve's address.
Evidence and Consequences
The panel chair, Ian Arundale, concluded that no search was carried out at Mr Russon's address or at Eve's address. He said: "The bulk of the evidence suggests no house search took place." Livingstone, who broke down in tears when giving evidence, had written on the investigation log for Eve that there was "nothing missing out of the usual that mum or dad were concerned over". Mr Arundale concluded the statement was misleading and said: "The entry gives the false impression that a search was carried out."
Four of the six allegations against Hardwick were found proven, and two others were found proven in part. All of the allegations against Livingstone were found proven. Dismissing the pair without notice, Mr Arundale said "there was high culpability, high harm, and high aggravating factors" in what they had done, and that their actions led to the "integrity of a missing persons investigation being compromised". Two other Gwent Police officers are due to face misconduct hearings concerning their handling of missing person reports in relation to the crash.