Two police officers have been dismissed after a misconduct panel found they failed to carry out adequate searches when a young woman was reported missing, and then lied about their actions. The grieving mother of Eve Smith, who died in a car crash after being reported missing, said: "We trusted the police to do their jobs."
Emma Borg reported her 21-year-old daughter Eve missing to police on Saturday, March 4, 2023. Almost two days later, early on Monday, March 6, Eve was found in a crashed car in the St Mellons area of Cardiff. Eve, along with 21-year-old Darcy Ross and driver Rafel Jeanne-Actie, 24, died in the crash, while Sophie Russon and Shane Loughlin were seriously injured. All five were trapped in the car for 46 hours before they were found.
Officers Dismissed for Gross Misconduct
PC Richard Hardwick and PC Lauren Livingstone of Gwent Police were both dismissed without notice following a misconduct hearing on Friday. A panel found they had failed to search the homes of Eve and Sophie when they were reported missing and later lied by suggesting they had done so.
Panel chair Ian Arundale found the actions of the officers to be "deliberate and misleading" and said they may have compromised the investigation. He said their conduct was so serious that the only possible outcome was for them to be dismissed.
Family's Emotional Response
After the officers were sacked, an emotional Ms Borg, along with Eve's sister Lauren Doyle, said the outcome of the hearing was an "important step" for their families. They were joined by members of Darcy's family, including her mum Clare, with both families holding back tears and consoling one another.
While holding a picture of Eve, Ms Borg said: "No finding or dismissal can undo what has happened or bring back Eve or Darcy. The pursuit of truth has come at an enormous emotional cost. We have repeatedly had to revisit most painful periods of our lives, recounting events that no family should ever have to experience. At times we have felt our own honesty and credibility were being questioned when all we wanted was help to find our girls."
Ms Borg continued: "We trusted the police to do their jobs, follow their procedures, and use their experience and resources to help us find Eve, Darcy, and Sophie. Instead, the dishonesty established during these proceedings undermined the missing persons investigation and the trust our families desperately needed to have in those responsible for helping us. These were not simply procedural failings; these were our daughters."
Details of the Misconduct
A misconduct panel concluded that Hardwick, 32, and Livingstone, 27, committed gross misconduct over how they handled the missing persons report made by the families of Eve and Sophie, following a five-day misconduct hearing at Rodney Parade. The panel found officers had failed to carry out searches at the homes of the two young women and later lied about doing so.
The police watchdog said the behaviour of the two PCs was "inexcusable", adding that they had failed in the "fundamental basics of policing". The hearing was told that although they were junior officers, they both had experience in missing persons investigations and knew searches should have been carried out. They then deliberately misled others about their actions, including on the investigation log, in conversations with their supervisor, and to the police watchdog. This amounted to "operational dishonesty", the panel was told.
Hardwick faced six allegations, including that he lied about searching the homes of the crash victims and that he also lied to his supervising officer and the police watchdog. Livingstone faced four allegations, including that she lied about searching the two houses, as well as making a dishonest entry on the log and lying to her supervising officer. Four of the allegations against Hardwick were found proven and two others were found proven in part. All of the allegations against Livingstone were found proven.
Watchdog and Police Response
Following the hearing, IOPC director of engagement Derrick Campbell said: "Our thoughts and sympathies continue to be with the families and friends of the young people who sadly lost their lives, those who were seriously injured, and everyone affected by this incident. The actions of PC Hardwick and PC Livingstone were inexcusable with both failing in the fundamental basics of policing; to act honestly and with integrity. Conducting property searches is a basic but essential part in the early stages of a missing person investigation. However, PC Hardwick deliberately lied during the course of the missing person investigation, claiming on police records and to his supervisor that searches had been completed. To add to this, when given an opportunity to provide a truthful account, he lied to IOPC investigators. PC Hardwick would have known he was providing false information but he chose to do so any way. PC Livingstone had ample opportunity to tell the IOPC the required searches had not been conducted. Instead, she did not give an account and stated she could not remember the specifics of her visits to the homes of two of the young women who had been reported missing during her interview with the IOPC."
Chief superintendent John Davies of Gwent Police said: "Our thoughts remain with everyone affected by these tragic events. We extend our condolences to the families and friends of Darcy, Eve, and Rafel and recognise the continuing impact on those who sustained injuries that night. We understand the profound impact this case has had on their families, friends, and the wider community. It’s important that these matters were investigated independently and thoroughly in an open and transparent manner and then further examined at these hearings by the independent panel members. While the independent panel has reached a determination for two officers, we acknowledge that a further hearing is to be held to consider the actions of another two officers linked to the handling of the missing person reports."