A Metropolitan Police detective lied about his wife's death in a Barbados hotel room after abusing and drugging her throughout their 10-year marriage, an investigation has found.
Warren Arter, 54, told conflicting stories after his wife Rebekah, 47, was found dead at the luxury O2 Beach Club in June 2024. Arter gave conflicting accounts of her death, including that she had hit her head, been spiked, choked, or that he had awoken to find her dead, and vital forensic tests were not done, BBC's Panorama found.
Investigation and Family Concerns
The Met declined to send detectives to investigate, despite Arter - who led a rape investigation unit - being under investigation for sexual abuse, and a request by her family. Arter was arrested on his return to the UK for the alleged abuse of another woman and took his own life in HMP Wandsworth three days later.
His wife's family said police failed her by not immediately investigating her death. The Met told the BBC it decided against sending officers because no allegation of criminality was made. The authorities in Barbados concluded her cause of death was aspiration pneumonitis, inflammation of the lungs - but failed to preserve vital evidence or do a toxicology test.
Coroner's Findings and Prior Offences
A UK coroner has since recorded an open verdict and raised the possibility of "deliberate concealment or obstruction of further investigation". Arter was dismissed for drug offences in 2023 after a seven-year investigation by the Independent Office of Police Conduct. The Crown Prosecution Service did not press charges. Arter then subjected his wife to sexual and domestic abuse, coercive control and drugging, the BBC investigation said.
He met his wife, a hairdresser, in 2006 when he was assigned to investigate her domestic abuse complaint. The coroner said Arter "developed hypersexualised behaviour" and "exerted coercive control" over his wife. The circumstances of her death were described by several eyewitnesses as suspicious.
Eyewitness Accounts and Police Response
A hotel security guard said Arter tried to go to a party after her death and kept changing his explanation, saying: "He was trying to find the right story and none of them added up." A supervisor said Arter "didn't allow Rebekah to do anything on her own" and a receptionist said a staff member suspected him of drugging her.
Elliot Usher, Mrs Arter's son, reported her death to the Met. He said he had found hidden cameras, drugs and photographs of his mother naked and bruised at their home. Under Foreign Office guidance, the case for the involvement of UK police in investigations abroad is strengthened when families request assistance and there are credible concerns.
The Met said it made efforts to obtain the facts but decided it would not be appropriate without a claim of criminality. Commander Simon Messinger said: "Although criminal and misconduct proceedings concluded at the point of [Arter's] death, our inquiries have not stopped. We are working to examine his digital devices to identify whether there may be further victim-survivors or evidence of criminality."
He acknowledged Arter could have been arrested sooner and said "a complaint into whether further opportunities to prevent his offending were missed remains under investigation". Barbadian police had said they found no indication of violence and believed she had died of natural causes.
Nahar Choudhury, CEO of Solace, which supports women and children experiencing domestic abuse and sexual violence, said: "It is appalling that a police officer who was entrusted with investigating sexual violence was able to exploit and abuse the very women he was supposed to protect.
"The Met's repeated missed opportunities to hold him to account, their alleged attempts to obstruct investigations and the failure to review all the cases he handled show a deeply entrenched institutional failure that has left women exposed to further harm and denied the justice they deserve.
"The Met's apology and action in retrospect is not enough; there must be full accountability, an independent review of every case Arter handled and urgent transparent action to stomp out the misogyny and abuse of power within the force that continues to put women at risk."