Joseph Gerard Cancellare Jr. was arrested on Friday after allegedly sending a card covered in peanut butter to a woman with a severe allergy. The incident dates back to August 14 2025, when the unnamed woman, a best friend of Cancellare's ex-wife, reportedly found a blue envelope after returning from work in Plantation, Florida.
Upon opening the letter, she noticed a brown substance smeared on the inside of the card, which she identified as a nut-based spread. According to a report by Florida news outlet Local 10, she quickly washed her hands, but police say she still developed hives and experienced tingling on both arms for around six hours.
Alleged Alias and Return Address
The letter was allegedly sent under the alias "Goergina Sawals" and included a fictitious return address. According to a police report, the victim identified Cancellare from a security photo after police traced him to the location where the envelope's stamps had been purchased.
The woman also stated that Cancellare knew about her severe allergy, as they had socialised together on many occasions over more than 20 years.
Motives and Arrest
Police reported that Cancellare allegedly blamed the victim for the breakdown of his marriage. The victim stated that the last time they spoke was when she acted as an observer during the division of property following the divorce settlement.
Another individual reportedly accused Cancellare of being in full knowledge of the allergy and of repeatedly making comments about the victim and his desire to cause her harm. The woman told investigators she wanted to pursue criminal charges.
On Nov. 13, Plantation police arrested Cancellare. He was taken to HCA Florida Westside Hospital for a routine medical checkup before being transported to Broward Sheriff's Office main jail. As of Saturday morning, he remained held at Broward Sheriff's Office North Broward Bureau jail, with his bond set at $20,000.