London pub faces licence loss after landlord pool fight
London pub faces licence loss after pool fight

The Coningham Arms, a pub in Shepherd's Bush popular with Queen's Park Rangers fans, faces having its licence revoked after landlord John Lacey was reported to police over an alleged assault on a customer.

The incident followed a dispute over a game of pool at the pub on Uxbridge Road. John Lacey, who has run the establishment for more than a decade, was reported to the police in late August by the alleged victim. The Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS) understands Mr Lacey denies assaulting the man, and an investigation into the incident remains ongoing.

Police report details the brawl

A Met Police report, filed with Hammersmith and Fulham Council requesting a review of the pub's licence, describes how, following a dispute over a game of pool, "a confrontation developed between John and a customer".

"The incident escalated into violence, with a female customer assaulting John before further disorder took place between multiple individuals," the report continues. "CCTV footage showed a member of staff actively participating in the disorder by assaulting customers and becoming involved in the fight. Additional individuals subsequently joined the confrontation before those involved moved outside the premises."

The report, compiled by PC Charlotte Bennett, claims the customer was then "assaulted by John and his associates", resulting in a fractured knee-cap.

Further licence breaches alleged

Subsequent visits to the premises raised further potential issues and breaches of the pub's licence. These included CCTV not being provided to the police until September 11 despite repeated requests, alcohol sales outside of the licensed hours, and smoking by staff within the venue.

"As a result, police have no confidence whatsoever that John is capable of promoting the licensing objectives or managing this premises in a lawful and responsible manner," PC Bennett wrote.

The council's Licensing Team Manager, Adrian Overton, filed a letter backing the review, as did one resident.

Public support for the landlord

Mr Lacey and the pub have received significant support, with 38 individual responses sent in plus a representation backed by more than 160 Queen's Park Rangers supporters.

"John has been running the Coningham Arms for years and we have been regulars since he became landlord," the representation reads. "In that time, he has turned this pub right around and made this pub 'our pub', where on match days we all know each other and where there are occasional first-time supporters visiting, often who have traveling form [sic] overseas, we all make sure they aren't strangers for long. John has created a unique match day experience for us all to enjoy.

"John has ensured that this pub is welcoming and a glance online shows there will be fans from overseas for every home game, from Ireland, Norway, Sweden, US and more and the Coningham Arms is known as 'the best pub to go for fans travelling from abroad'. This is quite unusual and certainly valued by us all, the loyalty at the Coningham is lasting and mutual."

The commitment of Mr Lacey to the Coningham Arms and his relationship with his customers is a theme through the letters of support, with one patron describing him as "calm and responsible when dealing with difficult situations".

Hammersmith and Fulham councillors are due to review the licence at a meeting on November 24. At a separate hearing on Thursday night (November 19), members approved a shadow premises licence for the Coningham Arms submitted by the freeholder, Emily & Cate Homes Ltd. The sub-committee was told the applicant does not intend on operating the premises itself, and that the intention was rather to protect it as a pub given the forthcoming review.