Gwent Police officers lied about searching missing women's homes
Gwent Police officers lied over missing women searches

Two Gwent Police officers failed in their duty to carry out searches for two missing young women who had been involved in a fatal crash and then lied that they had, a misconduct hearing has found.

The two women who had been reported missing had both been involved in a car crash in the St Mellons area of Cardiff in which three people died and two were seriously injured. All of the victims were trapped in the car for 46 hours before they were found.

Officers Found Guilty of Gross Misconduct

PC Richard Hardwick, 32, and PC Lauren Livingstone, 27, of Gwent Police were found to have committed gross misconduct over how they handled the missing persons report made on the day of the crash by the families of Eve Smith, who was later found dead, and Sophie Russon, who was seriously injured.

A misconduct panel which concluded at Rodney Parade on Friday said the officers had failed to carry out searches at the homes of the two young women and later lied about doing so. Their actions were described as “deliberate and misleading”, with the panel remarking their conduct may have compromised the investigation.

Panel Details Deliberate Misleading

The panel said the culpability and harm in their actions were high. The hearing was told that although they were junior officers they both had experience in missing persons investigations and knew searches should have been carried out. They then deliberately misled others about their actions, including on the investigation log, in conversations with their supervisor and the police watchdog.

This amounted to “operational dishonesty”, the panel was told. Mr Arundale said their actions affected the family and friends of Eve and Sophie, and also public confidence in policing.

Stephen Morley, barrister for Gwent Police professional standards, called for the two officers to be sacked and said their behaviour involved the “fabrication of evidence in an ongoing missing persons inquiry”. He said the failure to carry out searches, combined with the concealment of wrongdoing, was incredibly serious.

Families Testify About Missing Searches

Sophie's father Nathan Russon, Eve's mother Emma Borg, and Eve’s brother Zaine Smith, all told the panel earlier this week the two officers visited their addresses on the night of March 4, 2023, but said they did not search them.

Hardwick took the lead on the search at Sophie’s address while Livingstone took the lead at Eve’s address. The panel said there was contradiction in Hardwick’s evidence to the panel about the search at Sophie’s address. He said he could recall going to the bedroom but couldn’t recall “key details”.

At a previous hearing the panel heard Hardwick was accused of not doing a “proper job” with the searches, to which he replied: “I disagree.” Sophie’s dad Nathan Russon branded the two officers sent to his house at the start of the search as "liars".

The panel noted there were discrepancies in the evidence given by Mr Russon but found his discrepancies were far less significant than those in the officers’ accounts. “No search was carried out at Mr Russon’s address,” the panel chair Ian Arundale concluded.

Dishonesty Found in Officers' Actions

Mr Arundale also concluded that no search had taken place at Eve’s address. He said: “The bulk of the evidence suggests no house search took place.” He pointed to the absence of evidence from the former officers about the circumstances of the homes and said it was indicative that no searches took place.

Turning to their actions after the searches were not carried out, Mr Arundale said both Hardwick and Livingstone had been dishonest. Of Hardwick, he said the officer knew a search had to be done and he stated on the form that it had been. “He was dishonest,” Mr Arundale said. “As a result the basic premise of the investigation was based on false information.”

Livingstone, who broke down in tears when giving evidence to the panel on Wednesday, had written on the investigation log for Eve that there was "nothing missing out of the usual that mum or dad were concerned over". She admitted that how she filled in the section of the form asking whether Eve's address had been searched was "awful" but denied it was lying or deliberately vague because no search was carried out.

Mr Arundale concluded the statement that nothing unusual was missing was misleading. “The entry gives the false impression that a search was carried out.” He said her behaviour in filling out the form was a “deliberate act that misled… not just an ‘awful entry’.”

Panel chair Mr Arundale said their behaviour amounted to gross misconduct and breached multiple standards of policing, including honesty and integrity, orders and instructions, and duties and responsibilities.

In mitigation, Sarah Barlow for Hardwick said ordinarily he has always been “an honest, carefully, highly-regarded police officer and person”. She added his behaviour in this case is not conduct he has engaged in before “and those who know him would not have expected it”. David Toal, for Livingstone, said the panel had also received positive character references for his client.

Allegations and Next Steps

Hardwick faced six allegations, including that he lied about searching the homes of the crash victims and that he also lied to his supervising officer and the police watchdog. Livingstone faced four allegations, including that she lied about searching the two houses, as well as making a dishonest entry on the log and lying to her supervising officer.

Four of the allegations against Hardwick were found proven and two others were found proven in part. All of the allegations against Livingstone were found proven. The hearing continues.

Two other Gwent Police officers are due to face misconduct hearings concerning their handling of missing person reports in relation to the crash. After a lengthy investigation by the IOPC, the police watchdog announced in 2025 that six officers, including Livingstone and Hardwick, should face disciplinary proceedings. Sergeant Matt Jones and former PC Gareth Murphy are due to face a misconduct panel while two other officers were dealt with through internal disciplinary meetings earlier this year.