The family of a six-year-old girl killed in a New Year's Eve crash in San Francisco is suing Uber, alleging the ride-sharing company is liable for the actions of its driver. Sofia Liu was struck and killed by an Uber driver, Syed Muzzafar, while crossing a street with her family at a green light. Her mother and younger brother were seriously injured.
Muzzafar has been charged with vehicular manslaughter and gross negligence. Uber argues it is not liable because Muzzafar was not carrying a passenger at the time of the crash, and its drivers are independent contractors, not employees. The lawsuit, filed by attorney Christopher Dolan, claims Muzzafar was using the Uber app and was therefore an agent or employee of the company.
The suit alleges that using the Uber app while driving violates California's hands-free law, and that this distraction was the proximate cause of the collision. It seeks a jury trial on charges including wrongful death and negligence. Uber declined to comment but previously stated it deactivated Muzzafar's account and expressed condolences.
This is the first lawsuit of its kind against Uber, which typically requires drivers to have their own commercial insurance and provides additional coverage. However, because the accident occurred without a passenger, Uber's insurance does not apply. The incident has prompted calls from the San Francisco Cab Drivers Association for tighter regulation of ride-sharing services, including mandatory insurance coverage between rides.