The family courts are handling 41 cases concerning a "very significant number" of children found living in a religious community in Cheshire that is at the centre of a sexual abuse and human trafficking investigation.
Cheshire Police launched the probe after allegations of serious sexual offences, forced marriage and modern slavery were reported involving members of the Ahmadi Religion of Peace and Light in Crewe. In April, more than 500 officers took part in a large raid at the group's headquarters at Webb House and at two other properties.
Judge's ruling on interim care orders
Mr Justice Hayden has said in a ruling published on Tuesday that the issues in the cases arising from the police raid at the headquarters "have not been heard in the family courts before." The family courts are dealing with 41 cases relating to children found living at Webb House, with some concerning more than one child.
In a ruling from June, published on Tuesday, Mr Justice Hayden said a judge in Liverpool made several interim care orders for the children living at Webb House in May, giving Cheshire East Borough Council the power to take them into care temporarily. He said the "overwhelming majority" of the children were still living with a parent or other family member.
In the same judgment, Mr Justice Hayden dismissed a bid by the mother of two children previously living at the house to discharge the interim care order related to them. The mother told the court that those in the group "choose to live together and share resources" and that she felt she was "being dictated how I am to live my life and who is able to live with me."
The judge said this was "tendentious and manipulative" and there was "no legitimate basis" to discharge the orders, as returning the children to Webb House is "simply not a sustainable proposition."
Risk of return considered too great
He said: "The position may very well change, in relation to some of the children, as the police investigation proceeds and as further information is disclosed to this court. That time has not yet come, nor is it in immediate prospect."
He continued: "The contemplated harm is very serious indeed, and until such time as the evidential landscape becomes clearer, the risk of return to Webb House is manifestly too great."
The Ahmadi religious group, linked to a branch of Islam, moved to Cheshire in 2021 from Sweden. More than 100 people are believed to have been living at Webb House, a former orphanage and the group's base.
Publication of ruling allowed
Mr Justice Hayden said in his June ruling that several protests took place outside the property following the raids "expressing opposition to the presence of the AROPL community." The mother also sought to prevent Mr Justice Hayden's ruling from being published, citing concerns that it could "reheat" tensions in the community, which could cause the children and their parents emotional and physical harm.
Media organisations, including the Press Association, resisted the bid to stop the judgment being published. In a ruling in July, also published on Tuesday, Mr Justice Hayden ruled that his June decision should be published.
He said that while public debate had become "crude and polarised," it was not the court's role to "encourage the expression of views which accord with its own or restrict the publication of views which are misinformed and/or biased." He continued: "There can be little doubt, to my mind, that it is in the public interest to be informed that protective and safeguarding measures have been taken to protect potentially vulnerable children."
He added: "The issues in this case have not been heard in the family courts before. Modern slavery and people trafficking are new challenges for this jurisdiction. The right of the public to know that there has been an application to a family court for determination of these serious and pervasive allegations, emanating from the raid at Webb House, is, in my judgment, both pressing and necessary. Again, I emphasise that at this stage, these are allegations, not proven facts. Openness is intrinsic to maintaining public confidence in the administration of justice within the family court."
A number of arrests have been made in connection with the probe into the religious group, with 13 people on conditional bail. Anyone with information can contact Cheshire Police through the public portal at https://mipp.police.uk/operation/07CH26D76-PO1 or call 101.