A Northumbria Police detective who altered a judicial commendation made by a judge would have been dismissed if he had not already left the force. The misconduct hearing heard how DC Jason Cowell added his own name and the name of another officer to the document, which had been issued by HHJ Gittins, a judge at Newcastle Crown Court.
Unauthorised alterations
DC Cowell had not been instructed by anyone involved in the case to make the alterations and did not inform anyone that he was doing it. He also did not obtain the authorisation of the judge to make the change. The hearing was told that he submitted the judicial commendation to the court without telling them he had altered it, and he did not inform anyone involved in the case or the court of the changes before handing it in.
DC Cowell, who has since left the force, admitted that he personally made both alterations. He also admitted that he submitted the document to the court on January 26, 2021. Between January 17, 2021 and February 16, 2021, an investigation was carried out into the alteration of the commendation. However, the former detective did not disclose that he had made the alterations at any stage of the investigation.
Repeated opportunities to disclose
The hearing heard how he had repeated opportunities to do so in an email to Prosecuting Counsel on January 29, a phone call with the CPS on February 5, a follow-up email on February 8, and a final email to the CPS on February 16. The panel said that when asked at the hearing why he had not disclosed his involvement, he was unable to provide a credible or satisfactory explanation. He ultimately said that he did not know.
The hearing was told how the former officer had the Judicial Commendation emailed to him on January 26 by a colleague. The panel said: "Despite being given repeated opportunities to provide a clear and complete account, he did not disclose either his responsibility for the alterations or that the document had been sent to him by email."
Gross misconduct finding
The panel found that he had breached the Standards of Professional Behaviour in relation to Honesty and Integrity and Discreditable Conduct, and that his conduct amounted to Gross Misconduct. They said the former detective would have been dismissed without notice if he was still serving. He will be placed on the barred list.