Woman who conned friend out of £25k for fake pub avoids jail
Woman who conned friend out of £25k avoids jail

A woman who defrauded a friend out of €30,000 (approximately £25,000) over five years by claiming it would be invested in a pub in Lanzarote has been sentenced at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court.

Geraldine McGrath, 57, of Shangan Gardens, Ballymun, pleaded guilty to three counts of deception. Her victim, now in her early 80s, believed the payments were an investment in a bar in Lanzarote that would fund her retirement. The woman used money from her wages, then savings and her pension, and now has no real savings and limited financial means, the court heard.

Impact on the victim

In a victim impact statement, the injured party said her son died in 2010 and she has been unable to afford a headstone for his grave. Judge Jonathan Dunphy noted the statement, in which she says she continues to feel the loss of her savings. He also noted the value of the guilty plea, which spared the woman the stress of giving evidence at trial.

The court heard the pleas were acceptable to the Director of Public Prosecutions on a full facts basis and are representative of offending between May 2016 and August 2021. McGrath has no previous convictions.

Repayment and sentence

The case was adjourned several times to allow McGrath to gather funds. She has so far collected €18,500 (approximately £15,400) to repay the injured party and said she would need a further year to raise the balance. The judge noted there had been no indication of what the €30,000 was used for.

Aggravating factors included the breach of trust and the effect on the victim, who has been left significantly worse off in her retirement years. Judge Dunphy imposed a three-year sentence but suspended it in full on strict conditions, including that McGrath pay a further €10,000 (£8,300) within 12 months and have no contact with the injured party.

Background to the deception

At an earlier hearing, Detective Garda Damien Rogers told the court the two women became acquainted in the 1970s and reconnected about 20 years ago. They attended cabaret and music shows together, including during a trip to Lanzarote. The injured party told gardaí she spoke to McGrath about her love of the Spanish island and how it would be great to retire there if financial circumstances allowed.

McGrath later mentioned she planned to invest in a pub there and that the woman could invest through her. The woman handed over cash weekly, recording payments in a notebook. Amounts ranged from €100 (around £83) to a maximum of €450 (approximately £375).

Her family became concerned in 2018 and encouraged her to contact gardaí, but she believed the investment was legitimate. Over time it became clear there was no reality to the investment. The woman made a complaint to gardaí in 2022. McGrath denied the allegations and took a trial date, but indicated a guilty plea in advance of the October trial date.

The court heard the injured party said one of the main impacts was a disconnection from her family, which has since been overcome. McGrath has had no contact with the victim since the offending came to light, has not come to other garda attention, and has no trappings of wealth. She wrote a letter of apology to the injured party. Her counsel described the case as a "clear breach of trust", a "betrayal of friendship" and a "mean-spirited offence", adding that his client is remorseful. Medical reports were handed in, and McGrath has been diagnosed with breast cancer.