Instagram catfish Sarah Brennan fined for romance fraud
Instagram catfish fined for romance fraud

A Glasgow woman who posed as a man in online romance scams has been fined £2,000 and placed on the sex offenders register.

Sarah Brennan, 32, of Drumchapel, admitted two counts of romance fraud and stalking at Glasgow Sheriff Court in March 2026. She pretended to be a man named Matthew Jay to dupe one woman into sending nude pictures, and also claimed to be a male lawyer to another woman.

How the scam unfolded

Brennan messaged the first victim on Instagram in 2019, posing as Matthew Jay, who claimed to be Brennan's cousin. The pair swapped intimate pictures over six months, with Brennan sending images of "a male's body with no face visible," the court was told.

Her hoax was revealed when the victim chatted to Brennan's mum, who "did not know of any family members of that name." When confronted, Brennan claimed she had been "bored."

She then phoned her victim 250 times in one day, sent a screenshot of a map indicating she was near her home, and threatened to release explicit images. She also sent a card, a necklace and a pendant inscribed "stuck with you," prompting the victim to call police.

Second victim and sentencing

After her arrest, it emerged Brennan had contacted another woman online in 2021, again posing as a lawyer called Matthew Jay. She sparked suspicion by cancelling meet-ups, and the woman's loved ones traced the same Instagram profile to an Englishman living in Dubai.

He confirmed he had been "contacted before" and that his identity had been stolen by "a female in Glasgow, who had entered into an online relationship." The scam left her second victim suffering from panic attacks.

Michael Tierney, defending, said: "She is accepting of her guilt and has shown a great deal of reflection in regards to her behaviour." He added that as a result of her conviction, her employment was ended, and she is now applying for Universal Credit.

In August, Brennan was fined £2,000 and placed under supervision for 12 months as an alternative to a custodial sentence. She was also placed on the sex offenders register for five years, and a three-year non-harassment order was granted prohibiting her from contacting her victims.