A 57-year-old woman has been given a fully suspended three-year sentence after conning an elderly friend out of €30,000 (around £25,000) over five years by pretending the money was an investment in a pub in Lanzarote.
Geraldine McGrath, of Shangan Gardens, Ballymun, pleaded guilty at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court to three counts of deception. The court heard the pleas were acceptable to the Director of Public Prosecutions on a full facts basis and are representative of her offending between May 2016 and August 2021. McGrath has no previous convictions.
Victim used wages, savings and pension
The injured party, who is now in her early 80s, believed she was investing in a bar in Lanzarote that would provide for her retirement. She used money from her wages, then from savings and her pension, to pay McGrath. She now has no real savings and limited financial means, the court heard.
In a victim impact statement, the woman said her son died in 2010 and she has been unable to afford a headstone for his grave.
Payments and discovery
The two women became acquainted in the 1970s and reconnected about 20 years ago. They went to cabaret and music shows together, including during a trip to Lanzarote. The injured party told gardai she spoke to McGrath about her love of the Spanish island and how it would be great to retire there, if financial circumstances allowed.
McGrath later mentioned she was going to invest in a pub there and that the injured party could invest in it through her. The woman started handing over cash amounts to McGrath on a weekly basis, keeping a ledger of the payments in a notebook with dates and amounts. The amounts varied from €100 (around £83) up to a maximum of €450 (approximately £375).
The woman's family became concerned in 2018 about her financial situation and encouraged her to go to gardai, but she believed her investment was legitimate. As time went on, it became clearer there was no reality to the investment and the woman realised she had been deceived. She made a complaint to gardai in 2022.
Sentence and repayment
The court heard McGrath has gathered €18,500 (approximately £15,400) to repay the injured party and would require a further year to gather the balance. Judge Jonathan Dunphy noted the victim impact statement and the value of the guilty plea, which had saved the woman the additional stress of giving evidence at trial. He observed there had been no indication what the €30,000 had been used for.
The judge said the aggravating factors included the breach of trust, the effect on the injured party who has been left in a significantly worse off position in her retirement years, and that the older woman had trusted and relied on her friend in relation to an investment opportunity that never existed. He imposed a three-year sentence, taking into account McGrath's medical conditions, lack of prior convictions, remorse and her efforts to make good the victim's loss.
He suspended the three-year sentence in full on strict conditions, including that McGrath pay a further €10,000 (around £8,300) within 12 months and have no contact with the injured party. At an earlier hearing, Detective Garda Damien Rogers told the court that McGrath had been diagnosed with breast cancer, and medical reports were handed in for her and other family members. Counsel said McGrath has faced negative commentary on social media due to her offending.