A forensic expert has challenged the official finding that Jeffrey Epstein died by suicide, saying the convicted sex offender was strangled in his prison cell. Professor Michael Freeman said he believes Epstein was the victim of a homicide after reviewing files and photographs from the New York City medical examiner's investigation.
Expert cites injuries consistent with strangulation
Speaking to BBC Newsnight, Prof Freeman said the injuries indicated that Epstein had been strangled, most likely from behind, before his body was suspended from a bunk bed. Epstein was found dead at the Metropolitan Correctional Center in New York on August 10, 2019, while awaiting trial on sex trafficking charges.
His death was officially ruled a suicide by hanging following an autopsy conducted by the city's medical examiner. Dr Barbara Sampson, who was chief medical examiner at the time, has previously defended the conclusion, saying: "I stand firmly behind our determination of the cause and manner of death for Mr Epstein. The cause is hanging, the manner is suicide."
Evidence points to assault, professor says
Prof Freeman said his examination of the evidence had identified several injuries which he believes are more consistent with an assault. These included a deep haemorrhage to Epstein's left shoulder and injuries which appeared consistent with him being struck in the face. He also pointed to what appeared to be fingernail marks above the ligature mark on Epstein's neck.
Prof Freeman said these would be consistent with strangulation, particularly from behind, as a victim attempted to remove something tightening around their neck. He believes a ligature was used to strangle Epstein before the same material was used to suspend his body from the bunk bed.
He told the BBC: "The injuries and the way the body was found don't match up. There's only one remaining explanation then, and that is that the death was as a result of a homicide."
Independent review and official response
Prof Freeman has previously served as a cause-of-death expert to US attorneys-general in cases involving deaths in police custody, including that of George Floyd in Minnesota. He published his research and the medical examiner's files after presenting his findings at University College London on Monday evening. The material was provided by Epstein's brother Mark, who has consistently maintained that his sibling was murdered.
Prof Freeman said his conclusions were independent and that he had not been paid by Mark Epstein. He did not examine Epstein's body himself, basing his assessment instead on the medical examiner's documentation and photographs.
The original medical examiner reached a different conclusion, telling the US Department of Justice's Office of the Inspector General that the injuries were more consistent with suicide by hanging than homicide by strangulation. She also said there was no evidence of the defensive wounds typically expected in victims of strangulation.
Prof Freeman also questioned the handling of the scene, saying he would have expected photographs to have been taken before Epstein's body was removed. A Department of Justice investigation found that the prison guard who discovered Epstein immediately called for a second colleague, lowered his body to the floor and began attempts to resuscitate him. The report also noted that Epstein had been briefly placed on suicide watch a month before his death.
Asked who might have killed Epstein if his interpretation was correct, Prof Freeman said he had "no idea", adding that identifying a potential perpetrator was not part of his investigation. Epstein was convicted in 2008 of soliciting prostitution from a minor but avoided a lengthy prison sentence through a plea deal. He was charged again in 2019 with running a network involving underage girls for sex and was awaiting trial when he died.