A waste management company has been convicted of corporate manslaughter following the death of an employee who was struck by an excavator. John Graveson, 42, a picker at AMP NW Ltd, now operating as Waste Solutions Mcr Ltd, died at the Aspire House industrial estate in Dukinfield, Tameside, in March 2023.
A Hyundai excavator reversed over him, the trial at Manchester Crown Court heard. Jonathan Horan, 34, who was driving the machine, and company director Anthony Elston, 48, along with the firm itself, faced trial.
Guilty verdicts and cleared charges
On Tuesday, November 17, a jury unanimously found the company guilty of corporate manslaughter. The firm also pleaded guilty to failing to discharge a general health, safety and welfare duty to an employee.
Mr Horan, of The Crescent, Worsthorne, Burnley, was found guilty of failing to discharge a general health, safety and welfare duty to an employee as a staff member, but was cleared of gross negligence manslaughter. He was tearful as the jury returned its verdicts.
Mr Elston, of Wicket Grove, Clifton, was found guilty of failing to discharge a general health, safety and welfare duty to an employee as an employer. He was also cleared of gross negligence manslaughter.
An accident 'waiting to happen'
The trial heard that Mr Graveson's death was described as an 'accident waiting to happen', with the company having 'no identifiable safe system in place'. Prosecutor Alan Compton KC told the court: "The prosecution say this was an entirely avoidable accident. Because of the way the yard was being run by the company and Mr Elston, it was sadly an accident that was waiting to happen."
Mr Graveson, originally from Carlisle, was on his break at around 10.30am on March 3, 2023, when the incident occurred. Mr Horan was cleaning a compartment on a machine in the yard. "As Mr Horan carried out the task, Mr Graveson walked past the rear of the vehicle, which was stationary at the time," Mr Compton said. "Something caught his attention in a nearby waste pile and he picked it up and threw it away."
Seconds later, Mr Graveson began walking towards the toilet and welfare facilities. Meanwhile, Mr Horan had climbed into the cab of the Hyundai excavator and began to reverse. "Six seconds later, Mr Graveson was struck and crushed," Mr Compton said, adding that the machine was 'driven backwards and then forwards over him' and that Mr Graveson was killed 'instantly'. It was not the prosecution's case that the incident was intentional.
Unsafe yard operation
Investigations by Greater Manchester Police and the Health and Safety Executive found the yard was being run in a 'fundamentally unsafe' way, with a 'minimal' approach to health and safety, prosecutors said. Mr Elston was referred to as 'the boss' and was 'operations manager', while his wife Fallon Elston, against whom no charges were brought, handled the finances.
"The unsafe way the yard operated is the primary factor in this case," the prosecutor added. "The use of very large machinery and the existence of numbers of pedestrians in a relatively confined space... the potential for a collision was an obvious one. The prosecution case is nothing was really done by the company or Mr Elston to address that risk, despite the existence of extensive industry guidance, emphasising the need to place and separate pedestrians and machinery to minimise the risk of collision."
Mr Compton said the excavator's camera system, which offers a 360 degree view of the machine, was not active and the lens was 'covered by a blue protective film'. He told jurors the mirrors were not in the correct position. "If they were positioned correctly and had full use of the cameras, Mr Horan would and should have had full view of the area behind him as he reversed," he added.
CCTV footage from the days before Mr Graveson's death showed a 'chaotic, unregulated and dangerous environment', prosecutors said. In one video played to the court, workers were seen kicking a football around as machines were driven past them, with others 'milling around'.
Prosecutors said AMP NW Ltd failed to deliver proper health and safety arrangements, failed to conduct an adequate risk assessment, and failed to organise the workplace so workers and vehicles could circulate safely. The Crown also said there was no traffic management plan, that the company failed to ensure the excavator's 360 degree camera was operational, and that there was no safe system in place at the site.