Pontins fined £1m after grandmother died in ducting collapse
Pontins fined £1m after grandmother's ducting death

Britannia Jinky Jersey (BJJ), Pontins' parent company, has been fined £1million after admitting a health and safety offence following the death of a grandmother at a holiday park. Contractor Stephen Bennison, 60, from Farington, Lancashire, received a 10-month prison sentence suspended for 18 months.

Wendy Jones, 68, from Hereford, suffered devastating injuries when industrial ducting crashed down inside the Fun Factory entertainment hall at Pontins Brean Sands in Somerset on February 20, 2019. She survived the initial incident but spent almost six months in hospital before dying on August 4, 2019. A post-mortem examination later found a clear link between her death and the injuries she suffered in the collapse.

Refurbishment work blamed

On Friday (November 20), Bristol Crown Court heard how more than four tonnes of surplus soundproofing materials had been placed on top of the ducting during refurbishment work carried out several years earlier. The tragedy unfolded during a busy bingo evening when the ducting suddenly gave way inside the venue. Several holidaymakers were injured, and emergency services rushed to the scene.

Mrs Jones, who was attending with her daughter and grandson, suffered a fractured femur, fractured shoulder, broken ribs and a punctured lung. She had to be helped from the venue in her mobility scooter.

Investigation findings

Investigators later traced the disaster to soundproofing work carried out in 2015 and 2016. Contractor Bennison had been hired to reduce noise levels in the entertainment complex. During the project, soundproofing slabs were installed within the ceiling grid. However, the court heard that more than four tonnes of leftover slabs and plasterboard fascias were also placed on top of the industrial ducting.

When concerns were raised at the time, Bennison reportedly assured management the arrangement was safe. A survey completed in 2016 nevertheless identified concerns about overloading within the structure. While some work was carried out on the ceiling grid, the overloaded ducting remained in place.

The subsequent investigation found warning signs existed shortly before the collapse. Guests had reported concerns about visibly bowing ducting to Pontins staff, and some even moved seats because they feared it could fall. Experts concluded the additional weight had been added without proper checks, and warnings about the bowing structure were not acted upon.

Family statements

During police interviews, Bennison admitted placing surplus soundproofing slabs on top of the ducting to dispose of excess materials. He also acknowledged he had never previously undertaken soundproofing work on such a scale and held no structural qualifications.

In a victim impact statement, Wendy's son James Havard-Jones said: “My Mum’s life was cut short because of the incompetence and negligence of others. There is a temptation to describe what happened as an accident. I cannot do that. An accident is something unforeseeable. This was not unforeseeable. This was preventable.”

He added: “For six months, we watched her move between hospital beds, becoming a shadow of the woman she once was.” The court heard Wendy had been a well-known charity worker, community leader and devoted grandmother. Her daughter Hayley said: “People never think that they will go on holiday and then come back without their loved ones and it is not right that this happened to us.”

Detective Superintendent Roger Doxsey described the collapse as “entirely preventable”, adding, “It is a minor miracle, given the weight of the ducting, the nature of its collapse, and the volume of other people present in the Fun Factory at the time of the incident, that more people were not seriously injured and killed.” The case brings to an end a complex seven-year investigation into one of the most serious safety failures ever linked to a UK holiday park.