Pensioner accused of murdering 'soul mate' and hiding body in freezer previously jailed for fraud as fake vicar
Pensioner in murder trial was jailed as fake vicar

A pensioner accused of murdering his "soul mate" and leaving her body in his freezer was previously jailed for fraud after posing as a "fake vicar", a court has heard. Delia McInerney was found dead in George Gordon's flat on Gerards Court in St Helens alongside her five "beloved" guinea pigs, who he is alleged to have drowned, in January this year.

But the 62-year-old, from Anfield, was said to have been killed as long ago as April 2023, having apparently been hit over the head with a hammer. She had supposedly been planning to move to Portugal to begin a "new life" only days later.

Fraudulent activities before death

Gordon meanwhile bought a sledgehammer and electric handsaw from eBay in the weeks before Ms McInerney's death before stealing thousands of pounds from her bank account and taking out a £10,000 loan in her name. The 65-year-old is currently on trial at Liverpool Crown Court accused of her murder.

The jury of five men and seven women heard today, Tuesday, that the Department for Work and Pensions first raised concerns for Ms McInerney's welfare with Liverpool City Council in December 2025, having received a request to transfer her personal independence payments to a different bank account. The DWP was said to have been "unable to contact her twice" prior to December 2025, with a "support worker", who identified himself as Chris Cavendish Gordon, "having prevented visiting officers from speaking to her".

Concerns raised by social workers

Prosecution junior Katy Appleton read a statement to the court on behalf of council social worker Serena Fletcher, who said: "He called to cancel a face to face appointment and stated McInerney was due to start work on the 1st of December 2025 and to cancel her PIP. He said McInerney would write to the DWP and cancel her ESA claim."

Ms Fletcher subsequently visited Ms McInerney's home on Douglas Road but received no response, having spoken to neighbours before calling Merseyside Police to report her concerns. She subsequently returned to the property for a second time on January 8 this year and "again knocked at the house and got no answer".

Having "looked inside and seen that the house was very untidy", Ms Fletcher said she again called Merseyside Police to report her concerns and was told that officers would "make enquiries to trace her". Jurors were also shown an email sent by DWP worker Elspeth Samuel to another social worker, Dionne Coldicutt, on January 2, 2026, which read: "My research into this case has led me to this very concerning information about this 'support worker'. It appears he was in prison from 2013 to 2015 for fraud."

The email then referenced a BBC News article with the headline: "Fake vicar jailed for charity fraud. Bogus vicar gets five years. Conman bought reverend title from US website, court hears."

Ms Samuel's email added: "It appears he has set up and dissolved multiple companies, and has a history of forging signatures. It appears he has used several variations of his name."

Self-defence claim

Martin Reid KC, appearing for the crown, previously told the jury during the prosecution's opening earlier this month: "On the 8th of January this year, the police attended the defendant George Gordon's flat in St Helens. They went there because concerns had been raised by a number of people and agencies about the whereabouts and wellbeing of Delia McInerney."

"Ms McInerney had been friends with the defendant for many years and spent much of her time living at his flat, although she had her own house in Liverpool and property abroad. Ms McInerney's friends had not seen her for some time. The defendant, for over 18 months, lied to them about her whereabouts and sometimes pretended to be Ms McInerney when communicating with her friends by phone messages or email."

"Unbeknown to them, but known very well to the defendant, Delia McInerney had died in April 2023 at the defendant's hands. Her dismembered body was found in a chest freezer in the defendant's flat on the 8th of January this year."

"In the meantime, the defendant fraudulently obtained thousands of pounds from her bank accounts and obtained a loan and credit cards in her name. The defendant admits that he killed Delia McInerney but claims, we understand, that he acted in self-defence."

Gordon, who is represented by Gordon Cole KC and Philip Tully, denies murder and causing unnecessary suffering to an animal. The trial, before Mr Justice Goose, continues.