Sandie Peggie seeks new NHS Fife claim over 'spiteful lies'
Peggie seeks new NHS Fife claim over 'spiteful lies'

Sandie Peggie has launched a bid to bring a fresh legal claim against NHS Fife over what she describes as “damaging and spiteful lies”. The nurse claims three ex-colleagues told fake stories about her in the aftermath of a row over a trans medic using a female changing room.

The claim centres on comments those colleagues made about Peggie ahead of her return to work, which were described by service manager Charlotte Myles – who had taken the decision to lift the suspension – during a tribunal hearing in June last year. They included allegations of transphobia and racism, and that she had neglected patient care.

Witness statement details distress

In a witness statement submitted to a tribunal on Friday, Peggie said she was left “distraught and in tears” after hearing Myles’ evidence. The statement read: “I was particularly upset about what (senior nurse manager) Esther Davidson had said, because I had worked with her since around 2000 and liked and trusted her, and believed she liked and trusted me. We had been friends as well as colleagues. But all three respondents were long-term colleagues.”

Peggie’s lawyer Naomi Cunningham told the tribunal it was “no great surprise” to her client that some colleagues had opposed her return, given she had been “framed as the aggressor” in the interaction with Dr Upton. However, she said the comments had come as a “bolt from the blue” when she learned of them during the hearing.

Background of the case

Peggie previously brought a case against the health board after sharing a changing room with transgender medic Dr Beth Upton at Kirkcaldy’s Victoria Hospital in December 2023. An employment tribunal awarded Peggie a partial victory against the health board in December last year, upholding claims of harassment against her employer. However, they dismissed allegations of discrimination, indirect discrimination and victimisation.

Last August, Peggie raised further legal proceedings alleging victimisation and harassment by three of her former colleagues for opposing and lobbying against a decision to lift her suspension in March 2024. It also alleges the same of Fife Health Board, on the grounds it is legally liable for their acts. She had been suspended by the health board after raising her initial complaint.

Time bar dispute

Cunningham said learning of the comments resulted in her client suffering “injury to feeling” that would see her “entitled to compensation” if her claim is successful. The lawyer asked employment judge Joseph d’Inverno to extend the “time bar” to allow Peggie’s claim to proceed, on the grounds she had not known what the comments were until she heard Myles give them in evidence on June 21 2025.

The time bar requires that claims are made within three months – which the respondents’ lawyer Calum MacNeil KC said in his reply expired on June 17 2024, whereas the claim was not raised until August 6 the following year. MacNeil said Peggie’s legal team could have asked what the comments were long before this, as the health board had told them in December 2024 which staff members had raised objections to the ending of the suspension.

“It was entirely open to the claimant to investigate the details of who said what,” MacNeil said, as he asked the judge to dismiss the request to extend the time bar. He added that the latest claim is “part of the same story” as Peggie’s previous “wide-ranging” claim about how she was treated following the changing room incident in December 2023. He put it to the judge that since the “vast majority of the story” has already been heard, there is “no great injustice” if the time bar is upheld in this instance.

Judge d’Inverno said he would reserve judgment and issue a written judgment in due course.