Tributes have been paid to Judge John Curran, who has died at the age of 85, following a career in the legal profession that spanned decades. Colleagues described him as a "formidable" judge and "one of the most influential figures in law", with his courtroom operating like a "Gordon Ramsay kitchen".
Career and Notable Cases
Judge Curran served as resident judge at Merthyr Tydfil Crown Court. Educated at Cambridge University, he began his legal career at Hallinans in Cardiff in 1963. He became assistant recorder in 1989, a magistrate the following year, and a recorder in 1993. He was appointed circuit judge in 1996 and resident judge at Merthyr Tydfil in 1998, before retiring in 2012.
His hobbies were listed in Who's Who as walking, gardening, history, supporting Cardiff RFC, and "looking for my spectacles".
Judge Curran presided over a number of notable cases, including one involving a member of former Cardiff City boss Sam Hammam's security team in 2002, and dealt with a Brecon teenager who made a hoax bomb threat just after the September 11 attacks. He also sat for the "babies in the attic" trial, which he called a "sad and extraordinary story". He hit the headlines when a former call centre worker from Monmouth tried to use a bogus character reference from the Pope to hoodwink the judge.
Tribute from Judge Daniel Williams
Speaking at a packed courtroom at Cardiff Crown Court on Friday, Judge Daniel Williams paid tribute. He said: "We will all have our own memories of John... For many of us, our memories of Judge Curran will be of his time as a resident judge in Merthyr Tydfil. Put simply Judge Curran was a powerhouse – his ability amongst others to get extemporary reasoned rulings was second to none."
Judge Williams recounted a story of a 15-year-old defendant charged with wounding with intent, where an application was made for the defendant to sit outside the dock with his solicitor and his mother beside him. He said: "Judge Curran considered the application and passed in only the way he could the ruling: 'Well, she was sitting next to him in the pub when he glassed the victim so I don't see why not. Can you bring the jury in?'"
A 'Formidable Trial Judge'
Judge Williams described Judge Curran as a "formidable trial judge" with an approach most often on the "no nonsense end of the spectrum". He added: "There was nothing in the legal firmament to compare with a Friday list in front of Judge Curran in court one Merthyr Tydfil. I recently watched a series about rockstar chefs and I noticed similarities between a Gordon Ramsay kitchen and court number one. I'd call it JC at Number One or Curran at Merthyr."
Referring to Judge Curran as a "less sweary Gordon Ramsay", Judge Williams also recounted a story when a defendant told the judge he would show him his "great hairy a***" and then did so. After the defendant was removed from court, Judge Curran was asked if he wished him to return to be dealt with for contempt. He replied: "I've seen quite enough of him already."
Concluding the tribute, Judge Williams said: "I will always appreciate the kindness the judge showed me the day after my father passed. He was the most influential figure in law we have had the pleasure to know. He was formidable, intelligent, amusing, gruff, and kind. I pass on my condolences and the condolences of all of us here to Tori and James and all of John's family and friends. He will be greatly missed."
Judge Curran, who died aged 85 on November 9, was husband of the late Elizabeth Curran, father of James and Tori, and grandfather to Grace, Sam, George, Jessica, and Jake.