Gangsters' sentence appeal refused after hitman's cold feet
Gangsters' sentence appeal refused after hitman's cold feet

Two Scottish gangsters who conspired with a Liverpool hitman to murder a man in Glasgow have failed in their bid to have their prison sentences reduced. David Nisbet, 36, and Declan McCuish were jailed last year for their roles in the 2020 plot to kill Ryan Carvill.

Nisbet was sentenced to 13 years and McCuish to 11 years for conspiring to murder. The pair had agreed to pay the would-be hitman, James Richards, £70,000 for the killing. Richards was given a gun on April 11, with McCuish responsible for securing a hideout for him.

Hitman Pulls Out Over Getaway Car

The plot failed when Richards got "cold feet" on the day, expressing concerns about the car he would use to escape the scene. EncroChat messages showed Richards requested a faster car or a motorbike.

Richards' car was stopped by police on the M74 as he returned to Liverpool. While nothing of note was found in the vehicle, analysis of the encrypted EncroChat network, which had been hacked by European law enforcement, revealed the extent of his involvement.

Appeal Court Refuses Both Bids

At an appeal court hearing last month, Nisbet, who represented himself, told Lord Beckett, Lord Matthews and Lord Ericht that sentences given to others convicted of similar offences were shorter than his. He asked the court to reduce his sentence "in the interests of justice".

McCuish's lawyer argued the sentence was too harsh given his lesser role compared to the other conspirators, saying the original judge should have imposed a lesser term.

In a written judgement, Lord Beckett stated: "We are not persuaded that it was an excessive sentence, there was no miscarriage of justice." Both appeals were refused.