Bury killer's sentence appeal bid rejected by Court of Appeal judges
Bury killer's sentence appeal bid rejected by judges

Judges have rejected a bid to review the custodial sentence of Abbas Hussain, who was sentenced to seven years' detention in a Young Offender Institution in April this year for manslaughter. The Court of Appeal confirmed the application was refused after a hearing last Friday, meaning there will be no change to Hussain's sentence.

Hussain, of Windsor Crescent, Prestwich, stabbed Mohammed Isa Afzal, 19, to death with a 'Call of Duty-type' knife in the car park of a five-a-side football complex in Bury in the summer of 2025. The incident took place at the Power League complex on Market Street in Bury town centre. Hussain was 19 at the time, and 20 when he was sentenced.

Conviction and sentencing

Hussain was convicted of manslaughter after a trial at Manchester Crown Court. He was also found guilty of possession of an offensive weapon, but was found not guilty of a charge of murder. The case was referred to the Attorney General's Office for consideration, with the sentence subsequently referred up to the Court of Appeal by the office under the Unduly Lenient Sentence scheme.

The case was heard at the Court of Appeal by Lord Justice Stuart-Smith, Mr Justice Wall and His Honour Judge Shaun Smith KC.

Details of the attack

The trial judge, Mr Justice Lavender, told Hussain at his sentencing that Mr Afzal 'bore a serious grudge' against him. He followed Hussain into the car park at the Power League centre, then got out of his car and approached him with a baseball bat.

"You got out of your car and Mr Afzal swung the baseball bat at you twice. He hit you twice but, fortunately, he caused no serious injury. You produced the knife and stabbed him in the arm. He ran away and you chased him," the judge told Hussain. "You chased Mr Afzal to the exit from Power League and then back towards his car."

Mr Justice Lavender said Mr Afzal was taken to the ground. "That gave you the opportunity to run towards Mr Afzal while he was on the ground and to stab him a further seven times in four seconds," he said.

Impact on the victim's family

Mr Afzal's family, the judge went on, said their lives had been 'shattered beyond recognition' due to his death. "You ended Mr Afzal's life and you brought grief and misery to his family and friends," added the judge.

Mohammed Rayhan, 19 at the time, was accused of hitting Mr Afzal with a baseball bat, and Biryan Ak, 20 at the time, was said to have 'clothes-lined' the victim with his arm, bringing him to the floor. Following a trial, Mr Rayhan, of Chauncy Road, Failsworth, and Mr Ak, of Norman Grove, Longsight, were found not guilty of murder. Mr Rayhan was also found not guilty of possessing an offensive weapon.

Mitigation and sentence details

Gurdeep Singh Garcha KC, mitigating for Hussain, described the incident as 'out of character'. He said Hussain attended to play football with his friends and described the events as 'unforeseen'. "He did not seek out the deceased, and was not looking for him. There is evidence of regret. He has been the author of his own misfortune," the KC added.

The trial judge concluded it was 'a case of medium culpability'. Hussain, he added, had no previous convictions and had expressed remorse. "This was your first offence and it appears to have been a one-off offence because there was a particular issue between Mr Afzal and you," he added. "There is no evidence that you are likely to be violent towards anyone else."

Hussain will be released from custody no later than two-thirds of the way through his sentence.