The sister of a woman who disappeared the day after telling her family she wanted to leave her husband says the case is getting "serious traction" 20 years on. Margaret Haddican-McEnroe, then 29, went missing on October 10, 2006, and was last seen at her home in Warren Township, New Jersey.
Her sister, Adrienne Haddican, 45, saw her the day before, when she visited her parents. Adrienne claims Margaret expressed to their dad, Patrick, that she wanted to leave her then-husband, Timothy McEnroe, and take her three children. It took two days for Timothy to report Margaret missing, and according to local reports, officials have confirmed that he is still a person of interest in the case, as he was the last person to see her.
FBI reward and renewed hope
The FBI said in August that the agency is offering a reward of up to $25,000 for details leading to the arrest and conviction of those involved in her disappearance. Adrienne, a retired New York Police Department lieutenant, now living in New York City, said: "I do believe we are getting serious traction; people are not afraid to talk anymore.
"If someone shoved something down in the back of their mind, they are not escaping it. Somebody knows something; it is only a matter of time until we get answers. The fact that we still have no answers 20 years later is inexcusable. Margaret spent her life refusing to look away when people needed her, and 20 years later we are asking people not to turn away from her."
Memories of Margaret
Adrienne described Margaret as "fearless", "loyal" and "pretty wild". She said that Margaret was there for anyone who needed it, and would routinely turn up at her friend's house randomly to check in on them. "She was definitely one of those people where if you were lucky enough to be friends with her, she would show you a good time," Adrienne said.
"She was fun and would show up for anyone. Margaret was fearless, pretty wild, fiercely loyal. My sister would take you on an adventure that you would have never gone on without her."
Adrienne last saw her sister on October 9, 2006, a day before she disappeared. She was leaving her parents when Margaret pulled into the driveway, needing to speak to their dad, Patrick, who passed away in 2013. Later on that day, Adrienne claims that Margaret called her mum, Eileen, 83, and asked if she could come over with the three kids and stay with them.
The day she disappeared
Adrienne said: "She looked agitated; she went into my parents' house for a couple of minutes and then left. I asked my dad what it was about; she said she wanted a ride to the hospital for knee surgery. My dad said she was on the phone to someone, cursing and screaming at them, and then she slammed the phone down and said to my dad how she wanted to divorce Timothy and take the children."
Margaret's then-husband, Timothy, was the last person to see her, but didn't report her missing to the police until two days later. Adrienne found out that Margaret had gone missing the following Monday, October 16, and said she knew immediately that something terrible had happened.
She said: "In the beginning, there wasn't a lot of communication between law enforcement and us for a long time. When I found out Margaret was missing, my immediate thought was something terrible had happened. Especially the fact that Timothy had not reported her missing for two days. It was so out of the ordinary for Margaret to do this. When she didn't show up, I was putting pieces together in my own head that something had gone wrong."
Investigation and ongoing search
Margaret left behind three children, and Adrienne said it was her priority to be there for Margaret's eldest daughter and Timothy's stepdaughter, Sarah, who is now 29. At the beginning, Margaret told the police that her sister wanted to divorce Timothy but was told there was no indication that a crime was committed.
But in 2011, the FBI got involved with the investigation and conducted a two-hour search of the area - before naming Timothy as a person of interest in the case. Adrienne said: "I wasn't involved in the searches; I was in the background to support my parents and Sarah. I had told the police everything I knew and how Margaret wanted to divorce Timothy. They told me there was no indication that a crime was committed. Five years later, he was named as a person of interest and still is to this day."
20 years on from Margaret's disappearance, Adrienne believes they are getting serious traction in the case. Last year, their mum, Eileen, asked the family to come together and get renewed focus on Margaret's case.
Adrienne said: "It is sad to think that we might never know what happened to her, but I do think someone will be held accountable for it whether we know what happened or not. At the end of the day, we don't want another milestone - we just want to bring Margaret home. Sarah now has a three-year-old child; I keep telling her there is no way that Margaret would leave her."
In a statement provided to SWNS, Timothy said: "I, along with the kids who are young adults now, our friends and family all miss their wife, mom, and friend very much. We think about and talk about you every day. As far as being a person of interest, I have cooperated with everything they have asked of me. According to police, there are individuals that police have never questioned or stopped questioning because they have retained lawyers."
A spokesperson for the Somerset County Prosecutor’s Office, said: "The investigation into Margaret Haddican’s disappearance remains active and ongoing. Due to the nature of the investigation, we are limited in the information that we can provide at this time and cannot comment on specific investigative details, including the status or involvement of any individual. Detectives continue to follow leads and pursue information that may assist in determining what happened to Margaret. We encourage anyone with information relevant to this investigation to contact the Somerset County Prosecutor’s Office or the FBI, or to leave a confidential tip. We appreciate the public’s continued interest in this investigation."
Anyone with information about Margaret’s disappearance should contact the FBI and submit a tip online at tips.fbi.gov.