Wales urged to pause AI data centre approvals pending new guidance
Wales urged to pause AI data centre approvals

The Future Generations Commissioner for Wales, Derek Walker, has called for a pause on approvals of new AI-related data centres in Wales until clear national guidance and safeguards are in place. He said decisions on data centres need to consider their long-term environmental, social, cultural and economic impacts.

Walker has raised these concerns directly with the Welsh Government, calling for greater clarity and assurances on how the Well-being of Future Generations Act is being applied to decisions relating to AI infrastructure, and how communities are being meaningfully involved in decision-making processes.

The commissioner believes Wales has an opportunity to use its future generations legislation for responsible AI infrastructure planning by applying long-term thinking and sustainable development principles before significant decisions are made.

Major projects underway or planned

Data centres are needed to support the huge expansion in AI, but require huge amounts of energy and water. There are projects currently under way or planned across Wales, which collectively have a capital investment running into the billions of pounds.

US firm Vantage, building on its existing data centre campus in Newport, has begun work on a major data centre campus at the former Ford engine plant in Bridgend, as well as having plans for another campus at the Welsh Government-owned Bro Tathan business park in the Vale of Glamorgan. In Newport, part of the 230-acre Liberty steel site on Corporation Road has planning consent for a major new data centre from UK operator Era4.

A huge data centre, which would be one of the largest in Europe, has also been earmarked at a 700-acre site in the Dulais Valley owned by the Welsh Government. The site has been earmarked for the world’s first integrated train and rail infrastructure testing facility - the Global Centre of Rail Excellence (GCRE). The yet to be disclosed data centre company, which would require planning, is looking for an in principle agreement with the Welsh Government to acquire 10% of the site for its proposed project by Christmas.

Funding and investor concerns

The Welsh Government-owned company behind the GCRE said that the business rates generated by the AI data centre development, which annually could be as much as £20m, should be hypothecated to provide an effective guarantee that would give private investors the confidence to back the project. To date the GCRE has received £50m of Welsh Government funding and a £20m grant from the UK Government.

Investors have not been prepared to invest the £300m required to realise the project, which would have two testing tracks, without the Welsh Government providing some form of guarantee to reduce the risk. Earlier this month the Welsh Government called in a planned data centre project on a park and ride site in the Llanrumney area of Cardiff.

Commissioner's call for pause

Mr Walker said: “Artificial intelligence will play an important role in Wales’ future, and we should welcome opportunities for responsible innovation and investment - but we cannot afford to make decisions about major new data centres without fully understanding the long-term consequences and involving communities directly.

“That is why I am calling for a pause on approvals of new AI-related data centres in Wales until clear national guidance is in place.

“These developments will place significant demands on our energy and water resources, with implications for our environment, the communities living nearby and for our climate commitments.

“The political discussion around data centres has focused on potential economic benefits, but there has been far less conversation about other long-term impacts, despite the obvious strength of feeling from the public.

“As final negotiations are being made at the Climate Change Conference COP31 in Antalya, Turkey, Wales cannot determine the global direction of AI, but Welsh Government must ensure it listens to people and that decisions made here are responsible, transparent and aligned with our well-being goals.”

Welsh Government response

A Welsh government spokesperson said: “We believe in a sustainable and balanced approach to developing data centres. We recognise that data centres are energy intensive.

“As demand for digital infrastructure grows, it is important that new developments make use of technologies and approaches that minimise energy and resource consumption.

“Any proposed data centre development remains subject to the existing planning system and environmental regulation, with robust checks and balances in place to ensure that environmental and community impacts are properly considered before consent is granted.

“Wales is increasingly being recognised as a strategic location for the infrastructure needed to support the digital economy.

“Investment in data centres has the potential to create new economic opportunities and support skilled employment. But the Welsh government believes that the benefits of any investment must be felt by businesses, communities and in the wider Welsh economy.”

Welsh Government ministers are currently considering a new national policy for data centre development in Wales. The UK Government recently announced a new covenant for data centre development in England. Enterprise Minister Adam Price said: “The Wales of the future and the Wales of now needs digital infrastructure, including data centres. We’re creating a ‘Made in Wales’ version” of the UK government’s data centre covenant.” He added this would provide a clearer framework would support investors and local communities.