M&S Trench Coat Test: The £95 Classic vs. The Casual Cropped Winner
M&S Trench Coat Review: Classic vs. Cropped Style

Every fashion enthusiast understands that a quality trench coat remains a timeless staple in any wardrobe. As the new season arrives, this classic silhouette is set to dominate high streets across the nation. Marks and Spencer has recently introduced a brand-new trench coat priced at £95, designed to embody all the elements of a wardrobe essential. It features sharp lapels, a flattering belted waist, and that polished, versatile appeal that makes trench coats a perennial favourite.

The Shopping Mission

Despite working as a fashion writer, I must confess that I did not own a decent trench coat. When M&S launched its latest piece, I decided it was the perfect opportunity to rectify this. I visited my local M&S store with the intention of trying on the new trench coat. The question was whether I would leave with this classic item or if my search for the ideal spring layer would continue.

First Impressions of the Classic Trench

I located the much-discussed trench coat quickly, as it was prominently displayed at the front of the store. This positioning indicates that M&S expects it to be a popular choice this season. My initial impressions were overwhelmingly positive, scoring a solid 10 out of 10. The light caramel shade perfectly captures the essence of a timeless trench, while tortoise-shell buttons and a checked inner lining add a heritage feel.

Wide Pickt banner — collaborative shopping lists app for Telegram, phone mockup with grocery list

The coat is crafted from premium cotton twill, giving it a structured regular fit. It is not particularly lightweight, which might make it feel heavy on warmer spring days. However, the sturdy fabric makes it ideal for unpredictable British weather, where sunshine can swiftly turn to drizzle.

Trying On the Classic Trench

Upon trying it on, the quality was immediately noticeable. It felt expensive, with a structure and finish that delivered a polished, put-together look. As a tall individual at 5'9", the length fell just around my knees, providing good coverage without feeling overwhelming. I selected my usual size 10, which fit well overall, though it was slightly more oversized than anticipated—a point to consider for those preferring a neater fit.

Personally, I found myself preferring to wear it open rather than belted for the classic cinched-waist effect. This preference likely reflects my casual dressing style more than any flaw in the coat itself. Ultimately, while I initially thought I would add this trench to my wardrobe, its elegant and polished nature felt too formal for my day-to-day outfits.

The Unexpected Discovery

Just as I was about to leave the store, I spotted a different trench coat. This shorter version, priced at £60, offered a more relaxed take on the traditional longline style. I could not resist trying it on. It comes in a soothing green hue, which sets it apart from the usual caramel colour, yet retains timeless details like a double-breasted front, tie belt, and checked lining.

The cropped length meant it did not overwhelm my frame, allowing me to showcase my figure more freely. Additionally, its lightweight construction makes it an excellent layer for spring. This shorter trench coat aligns better with my casual style, feeling easy to throw on and versatile for everyday wear.

Market Comparisons

It is not just me who appreciates the shorter version. Other high-street retailers have introduced similar styles, such as a funnel-necked iteration from Mango priced at £59.99 and Topshop's burgundy take on the trend for £58.50. This indicates a growing trend towards more casual, cropped trench coats in the fashion market.

Final Verdict

While the classic £95 trench coat from M&S is a brilliant investment for those who love a timeless, polished look, it turned out not to be the right fit for my personal style. Instead, the cropped version emerged as the winner, offering a cooler, more casual alternative. If you prefer a laid-back aesthetic that is easy to incorporate into your wardrobe, the shorter trench might just capture your heart—as it did mine, securing a permanent spot in my collection.

Pickt after-article banner — collaborative shopping lists app with family illustration