Gareth Kitching, the trader behind Porky's Grill and Clowbecks, has not returned to the Manchester Christmas Markets for the first time in nearly 30 years, saying he was "priced out" by a rent increase of £5,000. He has ruled out ever coming back to the event.
Kitching had traded at every Manchester Christmas Markets since they first began almost three decades ago. Last year he ran three stalls: Clowbecks and Porky's Grill on Piccadilly Gardens, serving hot roast pork sandwiches and sausages, plus a new grill stall on Albert Square.
Rent rise of £5,000 for a smaller stall
This year, Piccadilly Gardens is not in use for the markets, with stallholders previously based there offered different sites across ten city centre locations. Kitching said he was asked to pay £38,000 to return to Albert Square, which he claims is £5,000 more for a stall smaller than the one he had last year.
He explained: "We were quoted £38,000 for a 6m x 2m stall on Albert Square. Last year we had a 9m x 4m for £33,000 so that's a big increase."
"We made a decision not to. We had three sites last year, one on Albert Square and two on Piccadilly. But we don't do any there now."
'It's very sad'
Kitching is now trading at Chester Christmas Markets, which opened this week. He said the management there is more "reasonable" with pricing, allowing him to charge a fair price without "gouging the public".
He said: "It's very sad, I've been there at every single one - 27 years I've worked with Manchester Council on different jobs - Irish Festival, summer events, Christmas Markets, but no I'm sorry, it's about loyalty to traders - and that's no loyalty. I told them I'm sorry we won't be coming back."
Kitching said he had a Zoom meeting with two of the managers to decline the offer. He added that he knows of other former Manchester traders who have also rejected the increase, with some choosing to go to York instead.
Council defends fees
Manchester Council declined to comment on individual commercial agreements but issued a statement on the rising rents. A spokesperson said the fees charged to market traders cover the cost of safely delivering the markets, which are unfunded and rely on stallholders meeting all costs.
The statement said these costs include power and lighting on each site, safety contracts for security and medics, and the safe design and build of infrastructure at each location. It added that rising costs of these basics, along with maintaining infrastructure and improving the festive experience, have to be passed on to traders through rental fees.
Kitching, aged 56, said he had hoped to trade for another five years with Manchester but accepted it was "not to be". He said Albert Square "does look very nice" this year, but not at the price for traders, noting that he uses small independent suppliers and supports local with his meats, which costs more.