A taste test of jam biscuits has crowned Aldi and Lidl as joint winners, with both supermarket versions scoring 10/10 and outperforming well-known brands Jammie Dodgers and Fox's.
Mia O'Hare, Senior Audience Writer for Spare Time, compared jam biscuits from Aldi, Asda, Lidl and Marks and Spencer against the classic branded options to see if any could beat them on taste.
Branded biscuits score highly
Jammie Dodgers, priced at 98p from Asda, received a rating of 9/10. The biscuit was described as having a nice crumbly texture that is soft to bite into, with a thick layer of raspberry jam that sometimes feels a bit thick and sticky.
Fox's, priced at £1.08 from Asda, also scored 9/10. The biscuit includes cream, which was found to be perfectly balanced with the jam. The jam was noted for having more of a tang than the rest, suggesting a higher-quality product.
Supermarket versions ranked
At the bottom of the rankings came Marks and Spencer, priced at 80p, which scored 5/10. The biscuit was judged to have too little jam for a jam-and-cream biscuit, with the ratio favouring the cream and making the jam hard to taste.
Asda's version, priced at 75p, came next with a rating of 8/10. It was the darkest biscuit of all those tested, which made it slightly firmer. It was described as a solid choice for a jam-and-cream biscuit, though the others tasted slightly better.
Winners revealed
Aldi's biscuit, priced at 59p, did not include cream and was described as tasting and looking identical to Jammie Dodgers. It had an ideal, soft, crumbly biscuit, and the jam was not as sticky or firm. This texture was preferred, making it the winner for a jam biscuit without cream.
Lidl's biscuit, also priced at 59p, came out on top among those that included cream. It had an ideal balance of jam to cream, feeling much more even than Marks and Spencer's. The biscuit was shortbread-like and crumbly, making it the perfect jam-and-cream biscuit.