Manchester approves 3,500 student homes despite backlash
Manchester approves 3,500 student homes despite backlash

Manchester council's planning committee has approved two applications for seven residential blocks that will create more than 3,500 student bedspaces in the city centre, despite strong opposition from neighbours and councillors.

The first application covers three interconnected blocks of eight, ten and 38 storeys at the Charles Street multi-storey car park off Sackville Street, delivering 1,041 bedspaces. The second covers four buildings, the tallest reaching 50 storeys, for a further 2,500 student homes at Weston Student Halls and the Pendulum Hotel on Sackville Street.

Residents raise quality-of-life concerns

Martijn De Roo, a resident of nearby Granby House, spoke against the Charles Street plans, warning that people's 'quality of life will plummet' if the development goes ahead. He described the area as once 'the springboard for city centre regeneration', but added: "These plans will seriously undermine that."

Mr De Roo also highlighted the visual impact of the proposed tower, saying: "I hope you can all appreciate the towering impact of a 38-storey very tall tower due south of us, not the slender structure claimed by the applicant."

Councillor Jon-Connor Lyons echoed those concerns, stating: "Residents are not opposed to the redevelopment of this site, nor are they opposed to purpose-built student accommodation. What they object to is the sheer scale of what is being proposed and the impact that it will have on their quality of life. We're talking about a 38-storey tower in close proximity to a well-established residential community."

Agent defends daylight impact

Niall Alcock, the agent for the Charles Street application, acknowledged the scheme's effect on daylight and sunlight, saying: "From the outset, we've acknowledged that this site has an impact on daylight and on sunlight. It's inevitable for anything replacing a low-storey structure with more dense development. It's openly and transparently addressed in the planning submission, and that is something that we've taken very seriously."

Mr Alcock described the impact as 'relatively localised' rather than 'widespread and catastrophic'. Despite the objections, the committee voted to approve the application.

Opposition to Sackville Street towers

The second application also faced opposition. Objector Chris Speck warned that September student move-ins would cause 'traffic chaos' in the area, and raised concerns about daylight, adding: "The most impacted homes will become more like caves, as so overshadowed and dark they will need lights on during the day."

Agent Olivia Carr defended the plans, saying: "Your comprehensive officer's report is clear that this is exactly the type of development that national and local planning policy seeks to encourage."

Councillor Ross Steven criticised the scale, stating: "This development will create four towers that sit many times above the height of buildings in the area. One sits at 50 storeys, over five times the height of local buildings, with others ranging from 17 to 33 storeys. This isn't a steady increase in density, it's a sudden, unmitigated avalanche of towers many times taller than the existing skyline, which will block out light for residents."

The Sackville Street towers were also approved by the planning committee.

Separate application deferred

A separate application for a new tower next to the Marble Arch pub on Rochdale Road was deferred. A council officer explained: "We've had a formal request from the applicant to defer consideration of the application. As members will have seen from the printed report, we've got an offer of units at Manchester Living Rent, and they would like the opportunity to continue discussions on how those units would be delivered. I think in this instance it's a perfectly reasonable request and I would recommend that members do defer the item on this occasion."