Property professionals have warned that the government's planned overhaul of leasehold ownership could disrupt property sales, increase costs and burden homeowners with new responsibilities if implemented poorly. Estate agents, conveyancers, barristers and managing agents broadly support the proposed changes, but caution that replacing leasehold with commonhold will not automatically make flats cheaper to own or easier to sell.
Some fear the government could repeat mistakes associated with the Building Safety Act, which created complications for leasehold transactions. The warnings follow the introduction of the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill to Parliament yesterday.
Concerns over Building Safety Act-style disruption
The legislation would make commonhold the default ownership structure for most new flats in England and Wales. It also proposes a £250 annual ground rent cap, changes to lease extensions and an easier route for existing leaseholders to convert to commonhold. However, several measures could take years to implement.
The Conveyancing Task Force has urged ministers to consult property lawyers, conveyancers and mortgage lenders before finalising the legislation. It supports the objectives of reform but fears that political promises could take precedence over practical realities. The organisation warned: "Too often, reform of housing law has followed a familiar pattern: political slogans first, practical realities later. The result is legislation that may be popular in announcement but problematic in implementation."
It pointed to the Building Safety Act as an example of legislation that created difficulties for property transactions. According to the Task Force, practitioners repeatedly raised concerns during that legislation's passage through Parliament. It argues that the resulting complexity contributed to uncertainty, delayed sales and financial difficulties for leaseholders. "There is a real danger that history repeats itself," the organisation warned.
Will reforms make homes easier to sell?
David Miller, divisional director at Spicerhaart Corporate Sales, said the real test would be whether the reforms improve the saleability of existing leasehold properties. He warned that short leases, escalating service charges and ground rent provisions already complicate transactions. Miller said: "However, the real test will be whether the reforms make a tangible difference to the saleability of the millions of leasehold properties that already exist."
He added that the problems also affect mortgage lenders. Leasehold properties account for more than half of the properties Spicerhaart Corporate Sales manages on behalf of lenders. Miller said: "The ambition is welcome, but implementation will be absolutely key to ensuring the benefits are felt across the existing leasehold market, not just by future homeowners."
Commonhold will not eliminate management costs
Another concern centres on the responsibilities homeowners will assume under commonhold. The proposed system would give flat owners collective control over their buildings, but they would also take responsibility for maintenance, insurance, repairs and financial planning. Andrew Hazeldine, real estate partner at Aaron & Partners, warned against assuming that removing a freeholder would remove those obligations.
"While the end of leasehold makes for a compelling headline and there is much in these reforms that leaseholders will understandably welcome, moving towards commonhold should not be presented as though removing the landlord removes the financial and logistical challenges of managing a building," he said. Homeowners would still need to arrange insurance, plan major works, collect contributions and deal with non-payment.
Under the proposals, existing blocks could convert to commonhold with support from 50% of flat owners. Hazeldine questioned whether homeowners would have the necessary experience and commitment to manage complex buildings. He also warned that third-party managing agents could continue charging fees under the new arrangements.
The Conveyancing Task Force raised similar concerns. "Commonhold may alter who takes decisions. It does not alter the underlying economics of maintaining buildings." It warned that some owners could face higher contributions if commonhold associations needed to build adequate reserves for future repairs.
Managing agents face a different relationship with homeowners
Robert Poole, divisional director of block management at Glide Property Management, said commonhold would fundamentally change who controls residential blocks. Instead of answering to freeholders, managing agents would become directly accountable to homeowners. He said: "Making commonhold the default for most new flats would give owners collective control over who manages their building, what work takes priority and how they pay for it."
However, Poole stressed that collective ownership would still require difficult financial decisions. He pointed to situations where residents might need to fund major repairs while continuing to pay for previous works. Clear accounts, reserve funds and long-term maintenance plans would therefore remain essential.
Mark Chick, ALEP director and senior partner at Bishop & Sewell LLP, also welcomed the proposed move towards commonhold. However, he said homeowners needed to understand the responsibilities involved before buying or voting to convert. "Commonhold gives owners more control. It also means making decisions together about repairs, reserves and who pays for what."
Chick called for practical guidance, trained advisers and sufficient resources at the Leasehold Advisory Service and HM Land Registry. He also warned that complex and mixed-use developments would continue to require experienced managing agents. "Much has been said about commonhold of itself 'reducing costs', but building management and maintenance costs will be the same regardless of land tenure."
Ground rent cap could face legal challenge
The Bill proposes capping existing residential ground rents at £250 annually. After a 40-year transition, the cap would fall to a peppercorn, effectively removing monetary ground rents from affected leases. The government aims to introduce the initial cap in 2028, subject to the legislation passing and the necessary implementation measures.
However, Chick warned that the proposed cap could face legal challenge. He also called for a clear timetable for implementing outstanding lease extension and enfranchisement reforms under the Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act 2024. The proposed changes include removing marriage value from lease extension calculations, but important valuation details remain unresolved.
Barrister Connect has urged leaseholders to seek legal advice before deciding whether to extend their leases or purchase their freeholds. Graham Smith, property barrister at 33BR Chambers, warned that the changes could take considerable time to implement. "Leaseholders should not assume that waiting is necessarily in their best interests."
Rory Nunn, managing director of Barrister Connect, echoed that warning. "However, the Bill isn't law yet, and nobody can promise when the marriage value change will land." The uncertainty could affect homeowners with shorter leases who face decisions about extending their terms or selling.
What happens next for agents?
The Bill must pass through Parliament before becoming law. Even then, ministers will introduce different measures in stages. Some leaseholder protections under the separate Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act 2024 are due to begin in April 2027. Further service charge measures are scheduled for November 2027 and November 2028.
For estate agents, the immediate concern is how uncertainty over future reforms could affect buyers, sellers and mortgage lenders. For managing agents, the challenge is preparing for a system that gives homeowners greater control without removing the cost or complexity of maintaining buildings. The industry broadly welcomes the ambition to reform leasehold, but its message to ministers is clear: changing the ownership structure will achieve little if the new system creates another set of obstacles for property transactions.