Barry pub to become flats despite 'cultural vandalism' claims
Barry pub to become flats despite vandalism claims

The former Castle Hotel pub on Jewel Street in Barry is set to be converted into eight flats, despite strong opposition from local councillors who described the decision as a form of cultural vandalism.

Permission to redevelop the site was originally granted in 2019, with plans to create affordable apartments while keeping the community pub running. A local residents' group, The Castleview Group, was set up to operate the pub, which was formerly run by Brains Pubs. However, in 2020 the group withdrew from the scheme, and the pub is now set to become residential units.

Split Vote Decides the Outcome

The planning committee was divided on the proposal, with seven members voting in favour, seven against, and one abstention. Committee chair Cllr Neil Thomas used his tie-breaking vote to follow the officer's recommendations and approve the development.

During the meeting, Cllr Nic Hodges voiced strong opposition, saying: "I feel short-changed, I feel conned, I see this as a form of cultural vandalism." Cllr Helen Payne expressed disappointment that there would not be a new community space but noted that the opportunity to house people in Barry who have suffered "a horrendous journey of trauma and homelessness" overrides that disappointment.

Developer Cites Lack of Interest

According to planning documents, the developer, Newydd Housing Association, carried out extensive marketing to find a new operator, but "there was no genuine interest shown in taking on the commercial/community element of the scheme".

The application states: "The leisure market has changed significantly since the planning permission was granted in 2019, exacerbated by the coronavirus global pandemic and the current cost of living crisis, and this has impacted upon the prospects for a viable public house in this location." It adds that there is limited appetite from leasehold operators to take on the pub as a 'shell and core' unit, and that the licensed leisure sector is facing significant challenges with cost pressures and staffing issues.

Council Objections and Concerns

Barry town council objected to the application, arguing that Vale of Glamorgan council should "enforce the original planning conditions and protect this important community asset". Cllr Ian Johnson said that "faith and trust" in the planning system is "eroded by people coming back and saying that they are unable to deliver that which they promised".

Cllr Carys Stallard, who also serves as the county's mayor, said: "I'm not convinced that it's the right place for more flats if I'm perfectly honest." The application argues that the development is compliant with local and national planning policy by promoting well-being goals and sustainable placemaking, with the aim of delivering cohesive communities and much needed affordable housing.