A joint review by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) and the Financial Ombudsman Service has found that half of complaints about delays to insurance claims were upheld in favour of customers. The first joint thematic report, published on Friday, examined almost 32,000 complaints specifically concerning claims delays investigated between April 2021 and March 2026. Around 50 per cent were upheld in favour of consumers, significantly higher than the 34 per cent upheld across all insurance complaints investigated during the same period.
Scope of the review
The review examined problems affecting home, car, motorcycle, travel and pet insurance, including delays in settling claims, poor communication and failures to keep customers informed about progress. Across the five-year period, the Ombudsman investigated around 66,000 complaints where delays, administration or customer service were recorded as the main issue.
The report highlights concerns about insurers failing to provide meaningful updates, repeatedly requesting information and leaving customers uncertain about who is responsible for progressing their claims. The watchdogs have urged insurance firms to improve their handling of claims, particularly where external contractors, repairers or other third parties are involved.
Key findings on complaints
The review found that around 215,000 insurance complaints were investigated between April 2021 and March 2026. Of these, approximately 31,900 concerned claims delays, while another 34,700 related primarily to administration or customer service. Complaints about claims delays had an overall uphold rate of 50 per cent, compared with 34 per cent for administration and customer service complaints.
Home insurance was a particular area of concern, with 53 per cent of complaints about claims delays upheld over the five-year period. The report highlights the difficulties customers can face when dealing with claims involving storm damage, flooding, fires or subsidence, where repairs and investigations can involve several different organisations. Problems can arise when insurers fail to monitor contractors properly or do not provide customers with clear information about the reasons for delays.
Vulnerable customers and industry response
The Financial Ombudsman also found that around a quarter of insurance complaints resolved during 2025/26 involved customers in vulnerable circumstances. These included people experiencing financial difficulties, bereavement, health problems or other circumstances that could make delays particularly difficult to manage.
Phil Smith, Head of Redress at independent insurance consultancy Broadstone, said the findings reinforced the importance of insurers maintaining high standards throughout the claims process. He said: "The findings of this regulatory review reinforce the importance of insurers delivering a consistently high standard of service throughout the claims process, particularly when customers are relying on their insurance cover at difficult or stressful times."
Mr Smith stressed that insurers remain responsible for customer outcomes even when other organisations are involved in processing claims. He added: "The FCA’s Consumer Duty places clear obligations on insurers around customer outcomes, and insurers will need to demonstrate that these principles are embedded throughout their claims operations."
Next steps for customers
The Financial Ombudsman considers complaints from consumers who have been unable to resolve disputes directly with their insurance provider. The review makes clear that not every delayed claim represents wrongdoing by an insurer, particularly where additional evidence or specialist assessments are necessary. However, firms are expected to handle claims promptly and fairly, provide appropriate updates and explain any delays.
Customers experiencing problems should initially complain directly to their insurer, setting out the issue and the outcome they are seeking. If the insurer does not resolve the complaint satisfactorily, customers can usually refer the matter to the Financial Ombudsman Service after receiving a final response or once eight weeks have passed without a final response. The service is free for consumers and can investigate whether an insurer has acted fairly and followed the relevant rules. Where a complaint is upheld, the Ombudsman may require the insurer to put matters right, which can include reconsidering a claim or paying compensation where appropriate.
The FCA has identified improvements to insurance claims handling and customer service as a regulatory priority for 2026/27, with the findings expected to inform further work across the sector.