Pension 'loyalty trap' could cost savers £61,877 in fees
Pension 'loyalty trap' could cost savers £61,877

Hundreds of thousands of people a year use pension drawdown, but research from consumer group Which? suggests that staying with the same provider could cost savers tens of thousands of pounds in extra fees.

Which? surveyed more than 1,700 people about what they did after they were able to use pension drawdown. This option is available to those aged 55 and over – rising to 57 from 2028 – who have a defined contribution pension. It allows savers to usually take up to 25% from each pension without paying income tax, with the rest left invested so the pot can continue growing.

Half of savers stick with existing provider

When people opt for drawdown, pension providers often manage and choose the investments for savers, typically putting money into their default fund. However, Which? found half of savers stick with their existing pension provider when they switch to a drawdown route, even though they could be paying higher fees through what it calls a “loyalty trap”.

The largest typical pension pot Which? analysed was worth £750,000. The lowest fee levied by providers worked out at £1,740 a year, while the highest was £6,638 – close to four times as much.

Fee differences over a decade

Over 10 years, and accounting for investment growth of 5%, a drawdown customer would pay £61,877 more in fees with the most expensive provider versus the cheapest. For a pot worth £250,000, Which? found fees ranged from £780 a year to £2,275. Over a decade, that would mean paying £18,658 more than with the cheapest option.

Platform fees are not the only cost to consider when weighing options for pension drawdown. Many providers require savers to get financial advice at some point in the process, and some are only available to advised customers. While financial advice can be incredibly valuable, Which? says such advice can be costly.

Which? urges shoppers to compare providers

Paul Davies, Which? pensions expert, said: “Retirees today are under immense pressure to make every pound in their pension count, but blind brand loyalty could quietly cost them tens of thousands of pounds over their retirement.

“Platform fees and hidden charges compound over time, quietly chipping away at your future spending power.

“It pays to shop around and be deliberate about what you actually need from a platform. Just a few hours spent comparing providers today could preserve a substantial chunk of your nest egg for the years ahead.”