Pension loyalty penalty could cost retirees thousands, Which? warns
Pension loyalty penalty could cost retirees thousands

Pension savers risk paying a “loyalty penalty” by staying with their existing provider for drawdown, which could cost thousands of pounds more in fees over their retirement, according to consumer group Which?.

Which? analysed annual fees across 18 drawdown providers, examining different pension pot sizes. The largest pot analysed was £750,000. The group calculated that, with annual investment growth of 5%, a drawdown customer could pay more than £60,000 extra in fees over 10 years with the most expensive option compared with the cheapest.

Many retirees stay with their existing provider

A Which? survey of more than 1,700 drawdown customers aged 55 and over, conducted in September, found that half (50%) had remained with their existing pension provider when setting up their drawdown plan, rather than shopping around.

Paul Davies, a pensions expert at Which?, said: “Retirees today are under immense pressure to make every pound in their pension count, but blind brand loyalty could quietly cost them tens of thousands of pounds over their retirement.

“Platform fees and hidden charges compound over time, quietly chipping away at your future spending power.

“It pays to shop around and be deliberate about what you actually need from a platform.

“Just a few hours spent comparing providers today could preserve a substantial chunk of your nest egg for the years ahead.”

Industry experts urge a wider view

Becky O’Connor, head of pensions at PensionBee, said retirees need to make the most of their savings, paying attention to value for money, including investment performance, fee levels and customer service. She noted that drawdown plans differ and comparing them can be difficult due to different charging structures and services.

Marc Stewart, head of financial advice distribution at Skipton Building Society, said fees should not be looked at in isolation, as investment performance, withdrawal levels and changing income needs all affect how long a pot lasts. He advised savers to review their pension regularly and consider the whole picture.

James Wilson, long-term savings policy adviser at the Association of British Insurers (ABI), said comparing on cost alone only gives half the picture, as each provider has a different investment approach and drawdown options with different fees, risks and potential returns. He encouraged anyone considering drawdown to shop around for the product that best suits their needs.

A spokesperson for M&G said cost alone does not tell you whether a pension is delivering value, adding that charges matter but so do investment performance, the range of assets available and the features received for the money.