A family lawyer has warned that a little-known divorce rule could leave people facing an unexpected financial claim from their ex-partner years after their marriage has officially ended.
Speaking on his Better Call Kal YouTube channel, lawyer Kal explained how pensions can form part of a financial settlement during divorce proceedings, regardless of when the money was accumulated. He also highlighted a concerning aspect of the law which means even people who divorced decades ago could face a claim if they failed to take one important legal step.
Why your ex could be entitled to your pension
Kal explained that pensions are considered matrimonial assets under the law in England and Wales. Under the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973, they can be included in financial arrangements when a marriage ends, alongside property, savings and investments.
He said: "Under the law in England and Wales, your pension pots, your entire pension pot, every penny of it forms part of the matrimonial pot on divorce, okay? Your ex-spouse can make a claim on it. A court can issue a legal order splitting it between you."
Importantly, this does not necessarily apply only to money accumulated during the marriage. Pensions built up before the relationship began can also be considered, meaning people are not automatically protected simply because they contributed to their retirement savings independently.
Kal explained: "There is no hard rule that only limits claims to pension growth that was made during the marriage." However, courts consider the circumstances of each case, including the length of the marriage and the wider financial situation. He added that the basic State Pension cannot be shared in the same way, but private pensions, workplace schemes and personal pensions can all be considered.
How much of your pension could your ex receive?
There are three main ways pensions can be dealt with during divorce proceedings, according to Kal. The most common is a pension sharing order, which allows a percentage of one person's pension to be transferred into a separate pot belonging to their former partner. Once completed, the two individuals have independent pension arrangements.
Another possibility is a pension attachment order. Rather than receiving their own pension fund immediately, the former spouse becomes entitled to a proportion of the pension income or lump sum when the other person retires. Kal explained that this can leave former partners financially connected for decades, making it a less popular option.
A third approach is pension offsetting. This involves one person keeping their pension while the other receives a greater share of different assets, such as the family home, to compensate.
But how does a court decide what percentage someone receives? Kal explained that the starting point is fairness rather than automatically dividing everything equally. Under Section 25 of the Matrimonial Causes Act, judges consider factors including the length of the marriage, financial needs, age, health and future earning potential. Contributions to family life also matter, including raising children and looking after the family home, rather than simply looking at who earned the most money.
The landmark case that shows why divorce may not be the end
Kal highlighted a case involving businessman Dale Vince and his former wife Kathleen Wyatt, which demonstrates how long financial claims can remain possible. The couple married in 1981 but separated just three years later, in 1984. Their divorce was finalised in 1992, when neither had significant financial assets.
However, Mr Vince went on to establish renewable energy company Ecotricity in 1996, eventually building a fortune estimated at around £57 million. Almost two decades after their separation, Ms Wyatt brought a financial claim against her former husband, seeking money despite his wealth having largely been accumulated after their marriage ended.
The dispute reached the Supreme Court, with Mr Vince arguing that allowing the claim after so many years was unfair. However, the court ruled that Ms Wyatt could pursue her claim, with the absence of a financial consent order from the time of their divorce proving crucial. The case eventually settled, with Ms Wyatt receiving £300,000.
Kal explained that it highlights the distinction between ending a marriage and formally ending the financial claims associated with it. He warned: "If you are divorced and you do not have a court-approved financial consent order on file, your ex-spouse has an open and indefinite financial claim against you right now against your pension, including against your assets as well and everything that you've built since divorce." He added: "Your divorce certificate alone is not evidence of a clean break."
What you should do if you're divorced or separating
Kal also warned that the introduction of no-fault divorce in England and Wales in April 2022 could mean more people are overlooking formal financial arrangements. The changes made it possible for couples to apply for divorce without having to prove wrongdoing, including through an online process. However, Kal suggested that the increased accessibility of divorce could leave some people completing the process without understanding the financial consequences.
For anyone currently separating, he recommended three important steps. Firstly, both partners should identify all their pension arrangements and obtain a Cash Equivalent Transfer Value (CETV) from each provider. These figures help establish the value of pension benefits and are generally valid for three months.
Secondly, anyone with a defined benefit or final salary pension should seek specialist advice before accepting the valuation at face value, as these schemes can be more complicated to assess. Finally, any financial settlement should be recorded in a court-approved consent order rather than relying on a private agreement or verbal understanding.
For those who have already divorced, Kal urged people to check whether a financial consent order was actually made. He suggested contacting their former divorce solicitor or the court that dealt with the proceedings if they are unsure. If no order was obtained, he advised seeking specialist legal guidance rather than attempting to resolve the matter without professional help.
His central warning was that the end of a marriage does not automatically mean the end of financial claims, making it important for couples to ensure their arrangements are properly finalised.