Heating experts agree: turning heating on only when needed is cheaper
Heating experts agree: heat only when needed is cheaper

Heating experts have settled a long-running household debate: it is cheaper to run your central heating only when you need it, rather than keeping it on low all day. More than a dozen people in the central heating industry gave the same advice when asked whether it is more cost-efficient to maintain a low temperature throughout the day or to heat the home only at certain times, such as when waking up or returning from work.

Why heating only when needed saves money

Patrick Garner, a gas safe engineer at Heatable, said: "If you have a gas boiler, it’s actually usually cheaper to set the heating around your routine. In other words, warm the house when you’re home, and let it cool down when you’re out. All modern central heating systems have a timer, so you can set it to automatically come on 10 minutes before your alarm goes off and 10 minutes before you get home from work. Because cooler houses lose heat more slowly, you generally use less energy overall."

Gordon Wallis, energy expert at Your NRG, explained: "Homes naturally lose heat through walls, windows and roofs, meaning your boiler has to keep replacing that warmth throughout the day, even when nobody is home. Using a timer or programmable thermostat to heat your home when you're there is usually more economical."

James Harrison, managing director at Fusion Electrical, said: "Your home loses heat throughout the day and the longer you maintain a higher indoor temperature, the more energy your heating needs to replace the heat you’re losing. It’s more cost-effective to let the home cool down when you’re out or you’re asleep and just bring it back up to a temperature you’re more comfortable with when you need it."

Practical advice from experts

Jamie Smith, energy analyst at Efficient Energy Consulting, noted that although it may cost a bit more to increase your home's temperature upon returning home or waking up, this does not cancel out the money saved by not heating your home to a low temperature all day. He added: "My approach would be to program the heating system to turn on approximately half an hour prior to rising, and to switch it off slightly before leaving the house."

Tom Nurse, energy efficiency expert from Fischer Future Heat, said: "Leaving the heating on overnight is rarely the most energy efficient or cost-effective choice for most households. From increased energy bills to unnecessary heat loss, the downsides often outweigh the benefits, especially when there are smarter ways to keep your home warm and safe."

Stephen Hankinson, heating expert at Electric Radiators Direct, said: "The black-and-white fact is that even a house with the highest level of insulation is always losing a small amount of energy when the heating is on so if you have your heating on all day you'll be losing energy all day." He recommends switching the heating on for a short burst of around an hour around the time you wake up, then again in the evening from around 5-9pm when most people are back at home. He added: "At night, it’s far more cost-effective to turn the heating off. A warm duvet or extra blanket is usually all you need to stay comfortable. The same applies if you’re out during the day – there's no need to heat up an empty home."

Reheating a cold house and other tips

Matthew Powell, founder of WarmZilla, said: "Reheating a cold house doesn't use more energy than keeping it warm all day as your home is constantly losing heat through the walls, windows and roof. The bigger the difference between the temperature inside and outside, the faster that heat escapes. So if you're keeping your house at 18°C all day while you're out at work, your boiler will keep switching on to replace heat you're not even there to enjoy."

Gareth Kloet, energy spokesperson at Go.Compare, and Tom Nurse of Fischer Future Heat, suggest simple ways to keep a home warm without turning the heating up further, such as using thermostats to schedule heating at peak times, insulating the home properly, adjusting heating room-by-room and not heating unused rooms, draught-proofing windows and doors, closing curtains in the evening to keep in heat, and making sure radiators aren't blocked by furniture.

Exceptions to the rule

The experts pointed out two exceptions. Stephen Hankinson said: "If your home struggles with condensation... keeping the heating on at a steady level throughout the day is wise, as condensation is less likely to build on warm surfaces such as walls and windows."

Patrick Garner said: "Things are a little bit different with heat pumps. They tend to work best with a steadier temperature. So, while you might lower the temperature a little while you’re out or asleep, I wouldn’t recommend turning it off completely."

Jamie Smith said: "Heat pumps are designed to operate continuously and intermittently changing operation can result in decreased efficiency. Homes with very good levels of insulation will retain heat for longer periods of time and under-floor heating systems take a long time to respond. Therefore, maintaining a constant operational setting may be suitable for these two types of systems." Gordon Wallis added: "Heat pumps can work more efficiently when maintaining a steady temperature, so the best approach depends on your heating system."