Marks & Spencer's fish fingers were named the best in a taste test of popular supermarket own-brand options, scoring a perfect 5/5 and beating Bird's Eye, which scored 4/5. The test, carried out by Reach reporter Emily Malia, compared fish fingers from Asda, Sainsbury's, Tesco, M&S, and Bird's Eye.
All the fish fingers were cooked in the oven for roughly 12-14 minutes at 200 degrees to ensure a fair comparison, though alternative cooking methods such as frying were noted as possible.
Asda and Sainsbury's Score Low
Asda's fish fingers, priced at £1.12, had pleasingly crispy and crumbly breadcrumbs, but the overall flavour was subdued. Emily said: "Indeed, they proved unexpectedly moreish owing to their lightness, yet you'd hope to feel adequately satisfied after your evening meal rather than left wanting more. Regarding flavour, the fish taste was distinctly subtle - simply not robust enough." She scored them 3/5.
Sainsbury's fish fingers, at 80p, were described as roughly half the thickness of alternatives like M&S, with a higher breadcrumb-to-fish ratio. Emily commented: "Taste-wise, it appeared strikingly similar to Asda's product, lacking much flavour, but in this case there's also an unsatisfying texture. It doesn't melt in your mouth or offer a satisfying chew either; it's a rather underwhelming eating experience." They received 2/5.
Tesco and M&S Impress
Tesco's fish fingers, priced at £1.15, were praised as an outstanding budget-conscious alternative with a creamy fish flavour. Emily said: "In terms of flavour, they certainly held their own, providing a markedly gentler fish taste that will appeal to those favouring milder alternatives, accompanied by a melt-in-your-mouth texture with minimal chewiness." However, she noted the result was rather soggier than competing brands, with the exterior lacking crispness and the fingers falling apart and sticking to the baking tray. They scored 4/5.
M&S fish fingers, at £2.50, earned full marks for their excellent taste and distinctly fuller and chewier consistency. Emily said: "The batter was crisp yet thinner in comparison to alternatives such as Asda's, though still excellent." She said she would readily buy them again, calling them more of a luxury option at a higher price than Bird's Eye, but in her opinion the additional expense is justified.
Bird's Eye Comes Close
Bird's Eye fish fingers, priced at £2.10, proved flavoursome, and while noticeably slimmer and paler in appearance, they were considerably chewier and brimming with superior flavour. Emily commented: "While their coating proved crispier and less crumbly, more reminiscent of a traditional fish finger — something Emily personally finds attractive — their original variety feels considerably more comforting and nostalgic to her."
Emily maintains M&S' fish fingers are superior, though Bird's Eye comes remarkably close and, at just 40p less expensive, remains a reliable option that won't disappoint. The test concluded with M&S taking the top spot among the five brands.