Quality Street beats Celebrations and Heroes in chocolate value test
Quality Street wins chocolate value test vs rivals

A comparison of Christmas chocolate tubs found that Quality Street offers the best value, with 60 chocolates in a 550g box, beating Celebrations and Heroes in a count test.

Mia O'Hare, Senior Audience Writer for Spare Time at the Daily Express, purchased three popular chocolate boxes from Sainsbury's, each costing £4.50. She counted the chocolates in each tub to determine which provides the greatest value for money, and also tallied how many of each variety were included.

Heroes: The Fewest Chocolates

The Cadbury Heroes box had the lowest weight of all the chocolate boxes at 475g, and contained the fewest chocolates overall. The tub had 50 chocolates in total. The variety was fairly balanced, with just two chocolate bars falling short of six pieces each.

  • Dairy Milk - 6
  • Wispa - 6
  • Creme Egg Twisted - 6
  • Dinky Decker - 6
  • Eclairs - 6
  • Fudge - 6
  • Crunchie Bits - 6
  • Dairy Milk Caramel - 5
  • Twirl - 3

Total: 50

Celebrations: More Than Expected

A Celebrations tub typically sparks fierce debate amongst families, as they battle over their favourites. Many people fear ending up with an abundance of Bounty bars at the bottom, as these tend to be widely avoided.

Yet, Bounty bars aren't actually the chocolate you receive the most of. The 500g tub is meant to include 51 chocolate bars, though the one purchased contained 54 inside.

  • Milky Way - 9
  • Mars - 8
  • Bounty - 8
  • Snickers - 7
  • Twix - 7
  • Galaxy - 5
  • Galaxy Caramel - 5
  • Maltesers - 5

Total: 54

Quality Street: The Best Value

The best-value box turned out to be Quality Street, as it had the highest number of sweets and the widest selection. There was variation between the quantity of chocolates you receive for each variety, with only five Green Triangles. In total, the 550g tub held 60 chocolates.

  • Orange creme - 7
  • Toffee Penny - 6
  • Caramel Swirl - 6
  • Fudge - 6
  • Strawberry Delight - 6
  • Toffee Finger - 6
  • Orange Chocolate Crunch - 5
  • The Green Triangle - 5
  • The Purple One - 5
  • Milk Choc Block - 4
  • Coconut Eclair - 4

Total: 60