For all the time we spend thinking about food, talking about food and scrolling through food, the question that dominates most of our lives remains stubbornly mundane: what’s for dinner? It’s the daily puzzle that underpins everything else, the meal squeezed in between work and washing up, eaten around crowded tables or in front of the television.
In her new book, But First, Dinner: Food for Our Real Lives, food writer Eleanor Steafel turns her attention to those ordinary meals and the lives built around them. Part cookbook, part memoir and part meditation on modern eating, it celebrates the dishes that reliably feed us, comfort us and bring people together. These are recipes designed not for performance but for real life – the sort of food that earns a permanent place in your repertoire because it works.
The recipes below capture that spirit perfectly. There’s a gloriously indulgent roast chicken au poivre with chips for when friends come round, a crisp fennel and cucumber salad that seems to improve almost any meal, a tray of Old Fashioneds built for sharing, and a strawberry and lime skillet cake made for long summer evenings. Together, they offer a reminder that some of the best food isn’t reserved for special occasions at all – it’s what happens when we gather around a table on an ordinary day and decide to make dinner worth looking forward to.
On the chicken au poivre, Steafel writes: “Ideally, I would like it if more things came ‘au poivre’. I love the slight sharpness, the just-enough-but-not-too-much cream, and the way the pepper dances on your tongue but doesn’t overpower like mustard might.” She notes that a spatchcocked chicken can cope with a luscious sauce while still giving golden skin, and the schmaltz and juices from the bird improve the pepper sauce, turning it into “something honestly a bit ridiculous”.
To make the dish, you start by roasting a spatchcocked chicken with garlic and olive oil, then prepare a sauce of shallots, white wine, double cream, crushed black peppercorns, Dijon mustard, lemon juice and white wine vinegar. The sauce is poured over the chicken partway through cooking, creating a peppercorn crust. Serve with twice-cooked chips for a truly memorable meal.