A father has been locked in a dispute with furniture retailer ScS for nearly a year after spending £2,700 on a new sofa set that he claims arrived damaged.
Stephen Partridge, 58, and his wife Cheryl, 52, bought a dark grey three-seat and two-seat settee set with built-in power recliner systems and a matching footstool from a ScS branch in Parkgate, Rotherham, in December 2025. The items were part of the Bagnolo collection.
Wrong colour and damage complaints
The couple had to send one settee back because it was the 'wrong colour and damaged'. Once the furniture was replaced, Stephen claims the new pieces arrived 'damaged' and was told he could not return them.
Stephen, a full-time carer for his wife, who has multiple sclerosis, said: "The whole ordeal was supposed to allow Cheryl and me to live comfortably in our home. But what was supposed to be a positive experience has turned into a nightmare. I'm bothered because I spent almost £3000, which is a big investment, and it needs to be right for my wife."
Independent report findings
Stephen spent over £200 on an independent investigator to assess the quality of the sofa. The £264 report identified multiple faults, including insufficient filling in the headrest, a dark discolouration embedded in the seat cushion fabric, a linear indentation measuring 10.5 cm, and excess material causing bunching. The report concluded that the suite was "not reasonably repairable cost-effectively or satisfactorily" and that replacement or full refund was the only satisfactory remedy.
However, ScS contests the report and has stated it will not replace the sofa. A spokesperson for Poltronesofà SpA, which owns ScS, said the company appointed an independent third party to investigate, and the technician found no manufacturing faults or defects.
Company response
The spokesperson said: "Since receiving their complaint, we have been in frequent correspondence with the customer. We appointed an independent third party to investigate and the technician they sent to inspect the product found no manufacturing faults or defects. As with all aspects of any soft upholstered furniture regular light dressing and plumping will alleviate the complaints raised, which the technician demonstrated on their visit."
They added: "We understand that the customer may wish to seek a further independent review and so we have suggested they refer the complaint to the Furniture and Home Improvement Ombudsman if they remain unhappy with our assessment and response."