Astonish vs Viakal: Which limescale remover won my tap test?
Astonish vs Viakal: Which limescale remover won?

In a direct comparison on bathroom taps and shower glass, Astonish Specialist Lime Blast Limescale Remover edged out Viakal Fresh Limescale Remover Spray, delivering excellent results at a lower price and without the strong odour that Viakal leaves behind.

Millie Bull, Deputy Editor of Spare Time, tested both products on hard water marks and watermarks around her bathroom. Living in the South East of England, she regularly battles limescale on fixtures and kettles, where the chalky mineral residue builds into a thick, crusty layer that often needs specialised products to shift.

How the test was set up

Limescale forms when water evaporates, leaving mineral deposits behind. It commonly appears in toilet bowls, on tiles, taps, shower screens and baths, as well as inside appliances such as kettles. In hard water regions, higher mineral content makes deposits more likely when droplets dry. As the marks build up, they become harder to remove, attract more limescale, harbour dirt and bacteria, and can even damage glass surfaces.

To ensure a fair comparison, Bull applied one product to her bath taps and the other to her shower, both of which were covered in watermarks and persistent limescale. She left each product to sit for five minutes before wiping them away with a damp microfibre cloth and buffing with a glass cloth.

Astonish Specialist Lime Blast results

Astonish has a more liquid formula and produces less foam than Viakal, yet it proved remarkably effective. Bull applied a liberal amount directly onto the bath taps, worked it in with a sponge, and left it for five minutes. After wiping and polishing, she said the end result left her genuinely impressed, with the product effortlessly removing limescale and watermarks without leaving any unpleasant odour.

It is also the more affordable of the two, priced at £2.50 from Tesco for 750ml. Bull noted she had previously used it to tackle limescale on her showerheads and confirmed it performed brilliantly.

Viakal Fresh performance

Bull described herself as a big fan of Viakal despite its rather strong smell. She regularly uses it to remove limescale from shower glass, where it works quickly and tackles even the most stubborn stains. In this test, she applied a generous coating to the shower, worked it in with a sponge, and left it for five minutes before wiping and buffing.

The shower gleamed when she finished, though she noticed a lingering bleach-like odour. Viakal is more expensive at £4.50 for 750ml at Sainsbury's.

The verdict

Both products did an excellent job of removing limescale from the taps and shower. However, Astonish is the more affordable option at £2.50 and leaves no unpleasant scent, while Viakal costs £4.50 for 750ml and leaves a strong odour but remains highly effective on stubborn limescale from shower glass. For taps and stainless steel, Bull recommends Astonish Specialist Lime Blast Limescale Remover.