Motorists stranded at temporary traffic lights stuck on red face a dilemma: wait indefinitely or risk driving through. UK driving law is clear on the rules, but there are serious risks to consider before acting.
The situation is especially frustrating at temporary lights controlling traffic in multiple directions, leaving drivers unsure whether the signals have malfunctioned or if there is simply an extended wait.
Automotive specialists at Auto Express have offered clarity on the regulations for drivers.
The Law on Red Lights
Steve Walker, head of digital content at the publication, explained: "By the letter of the law, you can't drive through a red light under any circumstances. If a traffic light is stuck on red, it's the responsibility of the authorities to fix it and/or get a police officer to direct traffic."
The Highway Code establishes the law in Rule 176. Motorists are instructed: "You MUST NOT move forward over the white line when the red light is showing. Only go forward when the traffic lights are green if there is room for you to clear the junction safely or you are taking up a position to turn right."
Nevertheless, Mr Walker acknowledged it might not be realistic to remain stationary if the lights genuinely are malfunctioning. He explained: "In practice, motorists faced with a stuck red light could be waiting for days if they stick to these rules and a little common sense will probably need to be applied."
Legal Consequences and Risks
The legislation outlining the regulations is Section 36 of the Road Traffic Act 1988. The law requires road users to comply with all relevant "traffic signs," and any driver who "Fails to comply with the indication given by the sign is guilty of an offence."
If you do choose to drive through the red light, Mr Walker advised exercising extreme caution. He stated: "This is obviously going to be easier to do in some situations than others. If you can see far enough to be sure that there's nothing coming in the other direction, it should be possible to negotiate a traffic light that's stuck on red safely."
However, he stressed that this is a hazardous endeavour and that you might be better off locating an alternative route. He warned: "You do need to make absolutely sure that it is stuck on red. You are taking a risk - both in the eyes of the law and, potentially, your insurance company if an accident takes place. In lots of situations, it may be better to turn around and find another route."
What to Do If Lights Are Not Working
Rule 176 also advises motorists: "If the traffic lights are not working, treat the situation as you would an unmarked junction and proceed with great care." This applies when the traffic lights have failed completely, rather than simply being stuck on red.
