World Rugby urged to punish Marx after new Dupont footage
World Rugby urged to punish Marx after Dupont footage

Fresh footage appearing to show Springboks hooker Malcolm Marx's fist making contact with France superstar Antoine Dupont has sparked debate and led to calls for World Rugby to take action.

The incident occurred in the closing stages of South Africa's 21-19 defeat to France in Paris last Friday. Some supporters questioned whether the reigning World Player of the Year's actions warranted punishment, while others suggested Marx may have been bracing himself for contact with the approaching French scrum-half.

Incident during final play

The incident took place during the final play of the match, shortly after Marx had released a pass. As Dupont approached, the South African appeared to look in his direction before clenching his left fist and moving his arm towards the Frenchman.

While there appears to be little force involved, the nature of the movement has prompted questions over whether it could constitute an illegal strike. It has led to swathes of fans voicing their opinion on the incident on social media.

"Why hasn't Marx been cited for this thuggery?" one asked. "World Rugby corruption! If Springbok management and supporters want every incident to be gone through with a fine tooth comb it won't go well for them."

"Yeah that's a cheap shot. 100%," another said. "Once their fist closes and moves forward, it's intentional," one claimed. Another said on Instagram: "You can clearly see him going from open hand to knuckle to hit Dupont in the face @worldrugby."

Springboks already under scrutiny

It comes at a particularly sensitive time for the Springboks, who have already been hit with two big disciplinary sanctions following their narrow defeat in the French capital.

Head coach Rassie Erasmus has been handed a six-match suspension following comments made about the match officials, while back-row forward Jasper Wiese has received a four-match ban for an illegal clear-out. Wiese's initial yellow card was subsequently upgraded to a 20-minute red card after his actions were reviewed, with the incident involving contact with an opponent above the shoulders during a ruck.

Now Marx has become the latest Springbok to find himself under scrutiny, although there is no indication that the incident involving Dupont is being formally investigated. The incident went unpunished by the match officials at the time and, with the usual citing window having passed, a retrospective suspension through the standard citing process is no longer expected.

Supporters defend Marx

Many South African supporters leapt to Marx's defence, however. "If someone slide tackles me football style and is about to break my ankle, I'm instinctively clenching my fist to brace for impact," one social media user said.

Another said: "Dupont is literally sliding into his knee caps in an illegal tackle. No wonder Marx is bracing himself and clenching his fist." A third claimed: "The player had a right to protect himself from another illegal knee-drop tackle which the match officials were refusing to penalise."

Nevertheless, the emergence of the footage has added another layer of controversy to an already eventful week for South African rugby. The Springboks take on Ireland this weekend with the game kicking off at 4.40pm on ITV1.