NZ media mock Wales despite historic All Blacks upset
NZ media mock Wales despite historic All Blacks win

Wales secured a historic 35-28 victory over the All Blacks in Cardiff, their first win against New Zealand since 1953, but the achievement has been met with scorn from sections of the New Zealand media.

Outspoken New Zealand Herald journalist Gregor Paul has questioned whether the result was a "pity win" and mocked the Welsh nation, while radio host Scotty Stevenson has insisted Wales are still "dog s**t" despite the upset.

Media reaction to Wales' historic win

Before the match, Paul described Wales as the 'Dickensian Orphans' of world rugby. Following the game, he wrote in the New Zealand Herald: "Could it have been a pity win? Maybe a country whose rugby team has declined in alignment with its post-industrialisation economic demise, won favour with the Gods."

He added: "The Welsh, the appendix of Britain in that a once important economic contributor to the United Kingdom ecosystem no longer knows its function, need their spirits lifted. They only see the sun twice a year, have come to view fish finger sandwiches as a delicacy worthy of being on brasserie menus and they are gripped by a crippling fabric shortage which leaves everyone barely covered when they head out for a Friday night drink."

All Blacks' worst defeat

Paul pointed out that the All Blacks have suffered some bad defeats in recent years, including three losses to Argentina, but believes the Wales defeat is the worst. "This is the one loss where it is legitimate to view it only through the lens of something having gone catastrophically wrong for the All Blacks," he wrote.

He noted that Wales were 10th in the world and had won just six games since the 2023 World Cup, against Italy, Japan and Georgia. "Maybe it was just sport at its brilliant, unpredictable and magical best. Wales defended heroically, attacked crisply and decisively and played smartly," he added.

Broadcaster stands by criticism

Last Friday, Scotty Stevenson, host of Sport Nation, labelled Wales a "garbage team". Even after the victory, he refused to give Wales credit. "I would urge some caution here. Yes, they have beaten the All Blacks, yes they have done so for the first time in 73 years," he said on Sport Nation. "But I'm just wondering are you prepared to say one team is a world beater and the other is dog s**t?"

He added: "I stand by exactly what I said. They have pulled an iron out of the fire here and that is why it's such a huge talking point. Not because Wales beat the All Blacks, it's because this Welsh team beat the All Blacks."

Coaches' frustration

Stuff NZ journalist Richard Knowler wrote that All Blacks coach Dave Rennie and forwards coach Neil Barnes would have felt like "chewing large chunks out of their knuckles" after Wales' win. "The All Blacks were expected to hammer them at the Principality Stadium," he wrote in Stuff NZ.

Knowler criticised the All Blacks' strategy, noting they turned down lineout drives and took three penalty taps instead. "The strategy to not kick for the touchline and back their set-piece and drive proved a spectacular failure," he concluded.